  鲜花( 152)   鸡蛋( 1)  
 | 
 
; R6 G# z3 u6 {" w2 y, e4 N4 z 
8 _7 K7 ?) J: ~) z 
8 C/ `4 {  u% }7 {6 s+ E/ i 
Randy Pausch’s Last Lecture: Really Achieving Your Childhood Dreams( i# `! e* I6 B) e6 Y, B 
Given at Carnegie Mellon University 
/ Q" v! j, M+ l  `1 P7 x5 r7 J( ZTuesday, September 18, 2007 
  O2 \5 ~: g1 y, M, ?% |McConomy Auditorium* u2 a' x# [5 P5 E! } 
For more information, see www.randypausch.com7 ~. ^' J5 M! d( `3 Z  j! {) l& \6 F 
© Copyright Randy Pausch, 20071 
# w4 `3 e# ~* x" }/ I, Y- r 
; `5 q% F4 i2 b; r3 _* f, T; UIntroduction by Indira Nair, Carnegie Mellon’s Vice Provost for Education: 
8 j: Y9 o" e7 w5 d; B& P  r0 THi. Welcome. It’s my pleasure to introduce you to the first of our new university’s lectures titled 
* c# @! B; O* P1 j4 HJourneys – lectures in which members of our community will share with us reflections and insights7 k! g/ Y$ {* t5 o( D1 Y 
on their personal and professional journeys. Today’s Journey’s lecture as you all know is by 
+ ^; ]/ h; k( \* ~( O" s1 iProfessor Randy Pausch. The next one is on Monday, September 24th by Professor Roberta Klatzky. 
  u3 t0 p- G) q) `8 Q6 c8 CTo introduce Professor Randy Pausch, our first Journeys speaker, I would like to introduce Randy’s 
. t+ j0 B+ N  p  E1 x6 P( Xfriend and colleague, Steve Seabolt. Steve has been at Electronic Arts for six years and is the Vice 
7 ^8 U" ~- G# K0 @/ E  NPresident of Global Brand Development for The Sims label at Electronic Arts. As you all know, The1 {9 D7 j) s& i3 J% v- M 
Sims is one of the most, if not the most successful PC games in the world, with sales approaching7 c2 ~/ a& z1 u. @) q% j" ` 
over $100,000,000. Prior to that, Steve was the Vice President for Strategic Marketing and, k$ L6 l( ]/ e" f; ~- w8 P 
Education at EA, bridging academia and Electronic Arts. His goal was to work with academics so5 i' ~! _& T: a4 x1 q8 K) ? 
there was an effective educational pathway for kids with building games as their dreams. It was in 
# s* _7 I1 `/ v, Ithat role that Randy and Steve became colleagues and friends. Before Electronic Arts, Steve was the 
4 S7 y% R& Y9 dworldwide Ad Director for Time Magazine and CEO of Sunset Publishing, which is a very favorite 
( Q) ^! [3 e$ _$ I( dmagazine in the Southwest, and as CEO there, one of the things he started was school tours,3 n/ r' c$ ]4 M2 M/ X& V 
because like Randy he shares a passion for inspiring kids of all ages to share their excitement for9 d9 S( o' ^* F! S 
science and technology. 
5 V3 G  B9 s- y2 WSo to introduce Randy, his friend Steve Seabolt. Steve? 
/ f4 A* [" P' s; I  l* c! D[applause]: F1 S! h: ?- O5 n 
Steve Seabolt, Vice President of Worldwide Publishing and Marketing for Electonic Arts (EA):  {. b! {  W/ _0 ~ 
Thank you very much. I don’t mean to sound ungracious by correcting you, but given that our PR( [1 C9 D( _7 } 
people are probably watching this on webcast, I’d catch heck if I went home and didn’t say that it$ _1 n5 ^/ {( K; K 
was 100 million units for The Sims. [laughter] Not that big numbers matter to Electronic Arts. 
+ ^" E' r: q4 e9 W* k2 l& w7 q5 n[laughter]% s6 G3 [/ m! c 
I don’t see any empty seats anywhere, which is a good thing, which means I just won a bet from 
- p# k2 }- p  k0 oRandy as a matter of fact. Depending upon who’s version of the story you hear, he either owes me- j" e3 b1 x2 h' g. N 
20 dollars or his new Volkswagen. [laughter] So, I’ll take the car.1 ~7 k2 c9 }2 q' L* t9 p- c7 \ 
It’s a pleasure to be here, thank you very much. I’m going to start by covering Randy’s academic! w% b8 u; j. U 
credentials. It’s a little bizarre for me to be standing here at Carnegie Mellon, which is a school I 
: X5 i9 V( O! W5 Lcouldn’t get into no matter how much I contributed to this institution. [laughter] But, no really, I’m8 K( a' L6 a! {# n5 p* @2 ^) H$ S 
not kidding! You all think, oh gosh he’s humble. Really, no, I’m not humble at all. Very average SAT8 a$ e2 o1 U6 |5 O3 j( x 
scores, you know, right in the middle of my high school class of 900. Anyway, Randy. Randy earned 
$ c! |4 W6 r1 A+ i7 z- @6 J6 G5 e– it really pisses me off that Randy’s so smart—actually I called him, we decided about, what, four 
6 L: d8 i/ Y% Zweeks, ago and we heard the news went from bad to horrific. It was on a Wednesday night and I 
" T# D. T, a* o+ j# rsaid look – we have two choices. We can play this really straight and very emotional , or we can go* K8 g+ `! k; n2 a1 \ 
to dark humor. And for those of you who know Randy well, he was like oh, dark humor! So I called 
" ~- ^1 Q) D8 `" r* s1 v+ W% Fhim the next day and I was like, dude you can’t die. And he’s like, what do you mean? And I said,1 D! J# z% ^# w' T, j  ~ 
well, when you die, the average of IQ of Seabolt’s friends is going to like drop 50 points. [laughter] To 
8 Q- M; @, ]" }4 x5 A+ w# g8 p: Ywhich he responded, we need to find you some smarter friends. [laughter] So you’re all smart& m0 _3 u+ ^! c9 h! p& K* ? 
because you’re here, so if you want to be my friend, I’ll be over in a corner of the reception room. 
( c9 h( Q- U- D& fRandy earned his undergraduate degree in Computer Science at Brown in 1982. His Ph.D. in CS from 
9 ?% R' S7 v. B/ dCarnegie Mellon in 1988 and taught at the University of Virginia where he was granted tenure a year4 N6 y% `2 e# W" @% P! | 
early. He joined the Carnegie Mellon faculty in 1997 with appointments in the CS, HCI and Design# y4 ]( ?. F6 ~& T% D: z 
departments. He has authored or co-authored five books and over 60 reviewed journal and, s  A' g& M: ~ 
conference proceeding articles, none of which I would understand. With Don Marinelli, he founded 
5 r7 @& i8 A" h! S- n9 X9 Uthe Entertainment Technology Center, which quickly became the gold standard organization for 
  t# s" I+ H9 e5 X& [training artists and engineers to work together. It is my view and the view of our company, 
. l9 U) L& X2 v. yElectronic Arts, that the ETC is the interactive program by which all others in the world are judged. 
* g# E4 r5 i, R8 PI met Randy in the Spring of 2004, and when I look back it’s sort of hard to imagine it’s only been 
: ~' I2 F: [- E6 H5 n4 i# Rthree years given the depth of our friendship. The ETC already had a very strong relationship with0 C, t( H( d" Y  b& x9 L6 Z7 K4 Q 
EA and with Randy. And Randy as he always does, for those of you who know him well, wanted to 
$ V9 W( ]& n$ n. k7 S0 Vlearn more, with his own eyes, about how the games business works, and how games really got5 x9 r2 ~, H) c# X 
made. So he spent a summer in residence at EA, and I was his primary contact point. We were in) r* R& ?9 z  m6 h/ B 
my view the odd couple. Randy the brilliant, charming, Carnegie educated CS professor. And me 
! F- ^5 b. v, N2 M/ l0 zwho went to the University of Iowa on a wing and a prayer. We spent a lot of time together that  u! x. c( u# B! d 
semester and for those of you who know Randy well, that’s a lot of turkey sandwiches on white8 L; u( C. s0 H# ^  O) c9 q/ G4 W 
bread with mayo. [laughter, clapping] My kids tease me about being “white.” There’s nobody more 
9 `4 Z* v6 }& {' e“white” than Randy. [laughter] We spent an enormous amount of time together. We taught each4 k1 t* c2 c/ R) Z 
other about each other’s very interesting, strange cultures to the other. Academic versus the5 w4 A# p' `1 M* N 
corporate world. And we developed a deep friendship woven together with stories about our kids,% K& @0 B( x& P* Z. V$ q  I 
our wives, our parents, as well as deep discussions about the paramount nature of integrity in 
8 y# e. p* \$ |* xeverything you do, family first, religion, our shared joy in connecting people and ideas, and6 M3 Z5 w; H( s0 X# D 
deploying money and influence to do good. And the importance of having a lot of laughs along the 
4 h! \3 ^. G  gway. 
# Z: r+ b3 Y, M" x9 D# TRandy’s dedication to making the world a better place is self evident to anyone who has crossed 
0 ~( P! c: p0 hpaths with him. Whether it’s directly influencing students, creating organizations like the ETC,7 `8 R' F- d8 J; @/ r 
building tools like Alice or doing what he probably does best, which is bridging cultures. As Ben+ Q6 y0 S% Y; [7 i 
Gordon, EA’s Chief Creative Officer, says of Randy, even more important than Randy’s academic,$ _- D: J5 l8 ]& K) G" L! }1 G 
philanthropic, and entrepreneurial accomplishments has been his humanity and the enthusiasm he 
/ |) i$ Z+ \0 Z: m+ H8 Abrings to students and coworkers on a daily basis.* B+ y+ d" r6 W; \) T/ r  [4 v 
For those of you who know Randy, Randy brings a particular zest for life and humor, even while 
7 D; ^1 K6 B. F# `2 ~. r6 \6 v- Y# d/ Nfacing death. To Randy, this is simply another adventure. It is my great honor to introduce Dylan, 
+ d! ]3 G2 D$ |7 d4 b& j6 s8 ]Logan and Chloe’s dad, Jai’s husband, and my very dear friend, Dr. Randy Pausch. [applause] 
/ q$ M# c  _0 rRandy Pausch:& y1 Y# X  b$ b- H0 f( u" U# { 
[responding to a standing ovation] Make me earn it. [laughter]2 V  b  A8 [8 K4 c, B 
It’s wonderful to be here. What Indira didn’t tell you is that this lecture series used to be called the 
: D8 y, |6 P: y- v& k, N$ eLast Lecture. If you had one last lecture to give before you died, what would it be? I thought, damn, 
+ W, P2 k( P& ?/ T0 V0 O4 @  vI finally nailed the venue and they renamed it. [laughter]1 w/ X7 F1 P# Z0 l 
So, you know, in case there’s anybody who wandered in and doesn’t know the back story, my dad: [4 }! h5 ~' m( B; [; x' B) g2 H 
always taught me that when there’s an elephant in the room, introduce them. If you look at my CAT 
# D1 d7 W# h9 ^$ K; Yscans, there are approximately 10 tumors in my liver, and the doctors told me 3-6 months of good  r, w/ C) G- S2 X& L 
health left. That was a month ago, so you can do the math. I have some of the best doctors in the+ M: ?" T: l1 N6 E 
world. Microphone’s not working? Then I’ll just have to talk louder. [Adjusts mic] Is that good? All 
- c' B0 ]% }; O, ]; }7 jright. So that is what it is. We can’t change it, and we just have to decide how we’re going to 
& M% {1 L0 a# d5 A& D0 X) n8 n1 Crespond to that. We cannot change the cards we are dealt, just how we play the hand. If I don’t- I/ {+ z2 `2 O( y0 y 
seem as depressed or morose as I should be, sorry to disappoint you. [laughter] And I assure you I 
2 J& `5 \! Y$ t; d! C" Ham not in denial. It’s not like I’m not aware of what’s going on. My family, my three kids, my wife, 
. P$ k4 j" \# j6 r, Uwe just decamped. We bought a lovely house in Virginia, and we’re doing that because that’s a' u' x# U3 x4 {1 ^ 
better place for the family to be, down the road. And the other thing is I am in phenomenally good, C* j8 y/ G2 y) |' u8 j 
health right now. I mean it’s the greatest thing of cognitive dissonance you will ever see is the fact. C# |8 ]& @7 A/ J: ^ 
that I am in really good shape. In fact, I am in better shape than most of you. [Randy gets on the6 F+ ^4 o6 @5 z# y6 Z% }$ E 
ground and starts doing pushups] [Applause] So anybody who wants to cry or pity me can down and 
1 C6 H( j7 J/ K* i  G7 F, Fdo a few of those, and then you may pity me. [laughter] 
1 [0 J9 v0 [' s% }; Z2 ZAll right, so what we’re not talking about today, we are not talking about cancer, because I spent a- Z6 N8 ~; m9 H& v# B3 l 
lot of time talking about that and I’m really not interested. If you have any herbal supplements or 
( W$ U5 c5 K- [3 k# R3 Hremedies, please stay away from me. [laughter] And we’re not going to talk about things that are 
. w; N$ u  J9 w/ Deven more important than achieving your childhood dreams. We’re not going to talk about my wife,4 o( Y9 J- d7 K0 V 
we’re not talking about my kids. Because I’m good, but I’m not good enough to talk about that 
7 h6 p8 `3 W" q+ I+ X/ K* W6 d( rwithout tearing up. So, we’re just going to take that off the table. That’s much more important.7 r) O) H5 |4 X 
And we’re not going to talk about spirituality and religion, although I will tell you that I have 
9 V% C3 ?6 T0 x, D2 ?achieved a deathbed conversion. [dramatic pause] … I just bought a Macintosh. [laughter and 
7 j4 [+ r* M7 b4 |& M- jclapping] Now I knew I’d get 9% of the audience with that … All right, so what is today’s talk about 
1 G$ k, K0 Q: r9 B  _7 J6 j3 z, e4 vthen? It’s about my childhood dreams and how I have achieved them. I’ve been very fortunate that! ^! X/ t! H, B! _$ M4 e) ` 
way. How I believe I’ve been able to enable the dreams of others, and to some degree, lessons6 m% X; V& l/ D0 ^: q- ` 
learned. I’m a professor, there should be some lessons learned and how you can use the stuff you 
! k& i, ~# N: G1 G+ whear today to achieve your dreams or enable the dreams of others. And as you get older, you may 
3 V$ A6 T) X/ X; y; V& _find that “enabling the dreams of others” thing is even more fun.4 g+ F. w" p* C1 a5 P6 j# o, I3 E& B 
So what were my childhood dreams? Well, you know, I had a really good childhood. I mean, no+ t/ I5 Z  r% `4 H" ^3 f 
kidding around. I was going back through the family archives, and what was really amazing was, I1 n# |9 X) ^6 G: ?1 u$ \ 
couldn’t find any pictures of me as a kid where I wasn’t smiling. And that was just a very gratifying 
6 A6 {/ I' ~2 l/ ]$ p7 ^6 k% @& jthing. There was our dog, right? Aww, thank you. And there I actually have a picture of me 
' v- i. R* \2 [, Y2 h: Ydreaming. I did a lot of that. You know, there’s a lot of wake up’s! I was born in 1960. When you) ^+ p4 S$ G7 x' c, F/ c 
are 8 or 9 years old and you look at the TV set, men are landing on the moon, anything’s possible. 
" x( w2 \3 R9 z' h- EAnd that’s something we should not lose sight of, is that the inspiration and the permission to 
2 R1 A! D/ C% _) f, G4 Fdream is huge. 
$ u( B, d, c# nSo what were my childhood dreams? You may not agree with this list, but I was there. [laughter] 
- D; M7 X* u9 x2 |1 N# dBeing in zero gravity, playing in the National Football League, authoring an article in the World Book 
$ [+ T8 y: b, P- A! v( QEncyclopedia – I guess you can tell the nerds early. [laughter] Being Captain Kirk, anybody here have 
& \) H; g( H: cthat childhood dream? Not at CMU, nooooo. I wanted to become one of the guys who won the big0 |. E; S5 ?5 M: P 
stuffed animals in the amusement park, and I wanted to be an Imagineer with Disney. These are not$ U2 Q# N. j8 J) h% [9 d3 X 
sorted in any particular order, although I think they do get harder, except for maybe the first one.' S( x* e" j- Z# _ 
OK, so being in zero gravity. Now it’s important to have specific dreams. I did not dream of being an 
* p  V8 r6 E+ O# s! i  @" iastronaut, because when I was a little kid, I wore glasses and they told me oh, astronauts can’t have 
8 ]4 O3 |1 C3 H6 f9 d, q7 @/ ^& C* oglasses. And I was like, mmm, I didn’t really want the whole astronaut gig, I just wanted the floating.0 D8 J6 \& `) |: ~ 
So, and as a child [laughter], prototype 0.0. [slide shown of Randy as a child lying in floatingformation. \! i- C; k# B5 M% ~! E* V4 `  _5 |  Q 
on a table top] But that didn’t work so well, and it turns out that NASA has something' i7 C" q/ R3 q+ f 
called the Vomit Comet that they used to train the astronauts. And this thing does parabolic arcs, 
0 S9 I  Q9 j0 s/ I, Nand at the top of each arc you get about 25 seconds where you’re ballistic and you get about, a 
: v$ N# M" O- w! B% vrough equivalent of weightlessness for about 25 seconds. And there is a program where college 
, [$ m# }  U. a; o! Hstudents can submit proposals and if they win the competition, they get to fly. And I thought that( l' h. \4 u" F' n' p 
was really cool, and we had a team and we put a team together and they won and they got to fly. 
/ i3 n, n! h! x( n$ e# cAnd I was all excited because I was going to go with them. And then I hit the first brick wall, because 
3 u. a: A1 ^$ M, ^3 f& uthey made it very clear that under no circumstances were faculty members allowed to fly with the8 ?/ t% l$ g' _8 J( o4 h" I3 s 
teams. I know, I was heartbroken. I was like, I worked so hard! And so I read the literature very 
6 l; o$ u8 S" lcarefully and it turns out that NASA, it’s part of their outreach and publicity program, and it turns 
) t* Y- Z$ [' |* sout that the students were allowed to bring a local media journalist from their home town. 
) r0 l: p# r5 n& C[laughter] And, [deep voice] Randy Pausch, web journalist. [regular voice] It’s really easy to get a* ^. W  C' [7 p  m! G/ \& { 
press pass! [laughter] So I called up the guys at NASA and I said, I need to know where to fax some 
3 D2 i- _( m7 p. Y4 V  wdocuments. And they said, what documents are you going to fax us? And I said my resignation as 
) F$ J: o" Y  B' R# Kthe faculty advisor and my application as the journalist. And he said, that’s a little transparent, don’t- g5 V2 J( q' q1 X* c  V5 n' v 
you think? And I said, yeah, but our project is virtual reality, and we’re going to bring down a whole 
& M+ b, o6 J  f1 X/ s/ Xbunch of VR headsets and all the students from all the teams are going to experience it and all those- p2 m9 P0 H7 n. y 
other real journalists are going to get to film it. Jim Foley’s [who is nodding in the audience] going1 E( {5 ^, S3 ^1 d4 l# v 
oh you bastard, yes. And the guy said, here’s the fax number. So, indeed, we kept our end of the# q$ t) M: C4 j 
bargain, and that’s one of the themes that you’ll hear later on in the talk, is have something to bring 
( I% r7 X5 ~) |% v- m5 J( Qto the table, right, because that will make you more welcome. And if you’re curious about what 
: X0 r( |% j- Y7 Azero gravity looks like, hopefully the sound will be working here. [slide shows videotape from  ^3 ~( }3 }; L" U2 J6 c) C5 u 
Randy’s zero gravity experience] There I am. [laughter] You do pay the piper at the bottom. [laugher,0 `3 G# Q. k# T+ R# o& W& e 
as the people in the video crash to the floor of the plane on the video] So, childhood dream number 
6 c' F* |6 V. r6 c5 oone, check.4 n2 ?" m8 H6 _6 {+ X  Q 
OK, let’s talk about football. My dream was to play in the National Football League. And most of* p. W! I5 ^( Z) r+ z7 h: [6 j 
you don’t know that I actually – no. [laughter] No, I did not make it to the National Football League, 
$ c$ S- U  p7 M) tbut I probably got more from that dream and not accomplishing it than I got from any of the ones  \5 O: H  z* `7 g 
that I did accomplish. I had a coach, I signed up when I was nine years old. I was the smallest kid in 
; U- Q: f- |4 y2 O7 |the league, by far. And I had a coach, Jim Graham, who was six-foot-four, he had played linebacker- ^9 L% K4 w8 A$ d# }) i 
at Penn State. He was just this hulk of a guy and he was old school. And I mean really old school.+ N1 X/ |* h, T0 u& H- w* H 
Like he thought the forward pass was a trick play. [laughter] And he showed up for practice the first 
% K" b2 L, q& g/ G* a, c0 _day, and you know, there’s big hulking guy, we were all scared to death of him. And he hadn’t 
& \# P, L) N' V( G" @brought any footballs. How are we going to have practice without any footballs? And one of the8 ~) S3 u$ k$ K0 h 
other kids said, excuse me coach, but there’s no football. And Coach Graham said, right, how many 
) ^3 O7 z7 I( P( x6 G) bmen are on a football field at a time? Eleven on a team, twenty-two. Coach Graham said, all right,& Y3 T9 P- c8 n- p8 Z 
and how many people are touching the football at any given time? One of them. And he said, right,  R  S9 ]: E% r- }4 k$ B* \! }) F 
so we’re going to work on what those other twenty-one guys are doing. And that’s a really good* F* t  _. a: w/ k$ ~' J 
story because it’s all about fundamentals. Fundamentals, fundamentals, fundamentals. You’ve got 
3 {2 B3 L2 ]5 r( N  }0 F! qto get the fundamentals down because otherwise the fancy stuff isn’t going to work. And the other$ q: R5 v9 W1 h. E! i 
Jim Graham story I have is there was one practice where he just rode me all practice. You’re doing7 `7 z  g6 _& [0 z# s 
this wrong, you’re doing this wrong, go back and do it again, you owe me, you’re doing push-ups& t1 H: C1 y. N  w/ l. x+ i 
after practice. And when it was all over, one of the other assistant coaches came over and said, 
1 }2 @0 U' D' L0 R8 h' [3 Dyeah, Coach Graham rode you pretty hard, didn’t he? I said, yeah. He said, that’s a good thing. He# X6 l3 U  D  Q! |, q; y# M 
said, when you’re screwing up and nobody’s saying anything to you anymore, that means they gave 
: H7 Z0 |7 G" h! Q1 hup. And that’s a lesson that stuck with me my whole life. Is that when you see yourself doing 
* i/ O8 `" s+ _1 L# esomething badly and nobody’s bothering to tell you anymore, that’s a very bad place to be. Your 
  }9 {# X$ r; L/ q9 X- ~7 [; B, pcritics are your ones telling you they still love you and care.) C6 l6 v2 M6 ^" g$ C8 H  N 
After Coach Graham, I had another coach, Coach Setliff, and he taught me a lot about the power of) N! n& }3 w; R. D8 r 
enthusiasm. He did this one thing where only for one play at a time he would put people in at like# h3 D7 B+ x) ~/ Y4 G1 E0 u2 N$ W 
the most horrifically wrong position for them. Like all the short guys would become receivers, right? 
# J4 n; a  K+ q7 h  ?4 K+ dIt was just laughable. But we only went in for one play, right? And boy, the other team just never3 Z, q2 f& M! j2 R0 w# K8 n 
knew what hit ‘em them. Because when you’re only doing it for one play and you’re just not where( {. B) T9 P, @" h8 S/ m 
you’re supposed to be, and freedom’s just another word for nothing left to lose, boy are you going 
2 R' V& M  X" q9 B* f8 H/ Xto clean somebody’s clock for that one play. And that kind of enthusiasm was great. And to this 
9 F3 d! E$ i# Z; t/ pday, I am most comfortable on a football field. I mean, it’s just one of those things where, you% J) ]. g0 [" Y$ K9 ` 
know, [pulls out a football] if I’m working a hard problem, people will see me wandering the halls8 q; n/ D- i+ O, _& s 
with one of these things, and that’s just because, you know, when you do something young enough 
7 j* m; ~  T1 `3 u4 l& Z) eand you train for it, it just becomes a part of you. And I’m very glad that football was a part of my 
5 i! W6 p) E0 k, xlife. And if I didn’t get the dream of playing in the NFL, that’s OK. I’ve probably got stuff more8 L5 O5 k' i- T  G; k 
valuable. Because looking at what’s going on in the NFL, I’m not sure those guys are doing so great' m- R% o$ b1 I- G 
right now.: ^6 C( Y# l! ^3 Y( y 
OK, and so one of the expressions I learned at Electronic Arts, which I love, which pertains to this, is" a+ M% Q& @5 D. @ 
experience is what you get when you didn’t get what you wanted. And I think that’s absolutely 
+ l, C* G2 y& Elovely. And the other thing about football is we send our kids out to play football or soccer or6 \0 B2 M/ F( z/ Y 
swimming or whatever it is, and it’s the first example of what I’m going to call a head fake, or 
# _+ S; |! i' }8 z0 X4 kindirect learning. We actually don’t want our kids to learn football. I mean, yeah, it’s really nice that 
  L5 k# _/ G* x- x  }" H. OI have a wonderful three-point stance and that I know how to do a chop block and all this kind of 
& C( l. g* C3 F4 f) O7 sstuff. But we send our kids out to learn much more important things. Teamwork, sportsmanship, 
. ^7 V% D5 C5 `+ h! b1 }  X" k9 eperseverance, etcetera, etcetera. And these kinds of head fake learning are absolutely important./ D+ ^2 q3 U& i$ f 
And you should keep your eye out for them because they’re everywhere. 
% z+ l) ?  c0 z" i* N9 LAll right. A simple one, being an author in the World Book Encyclopedia. When I was a kid, we had 
! h( n0 I+ i6 P, t3 k! othe World Book Encyclopedia on the shelf. For the freshman, this is paper. … We used to have these3 C, }3 t4 y' P1 f; p4 i% _ 
things called books. [laughter] And after I had become somewhat of an authority on virtual reality, 
$ k$ E5 T+ W$ y3 F/ Sbut not like a really important one, so I was at the level of people the World Book would badger.* \# r) Z4 \: a1 n# c) w0 x: ^ 
They called me up and I wrote an article, and this is Caitlin Kelleher [shows slide of Caitlin wearing, M) H2 b2 \1 i3 W5 l: [ 
virtual reality headset manipulating a 3D world], and there’s an article if you go to your local library4 |5 C. a! m1 ]7 ?1 Z, b) D, h 
where they still have copies of the World Book. Look under V for Virtual Reality, and there it is. And6 k9 A! {* |. L- Z  l6 Z: ^+ o1 R 
all I have to say is that having been selected to be an author in the World Book Encyclopedia, I now2 ^  p& w8 J8 l5 s 
believe that Wikipedia is a perfectly fine source for your information because I know what the  c' |9 A( {- J1 Y 
quality control is for real encyclopedias. They let me in. 
* `, w% ^4 D; p" kAll right, next one. [laughter] [shows slide “Being like Meeting Captain Kirk”] At a certain point you) O3 R2 n' }. b5 y- \* O6 Y7 N' ^ 
just realize there are some things you are not going to do, so maybe you just want to stand close to 
! n: q1 d4 P3 r4 y  ~the people. And I mean, my god, what a role model for young people. [laughter] [shows slide of 
- Y7 K1 Q5 a- Z5 J6 H' LCaptain Kirk sitting at his control station on the Starship Enterprise] I mean, this is everything you) \% Z) N7 _) ~$ Y8 \ 
want to be, and what I learned that carried me forward in leadership later is that, you know, he3 d2 h% Y! @: z9 p( x7 j 
wasn’t the smartest guy on the ship. I mean, Spock was pretty smart and McCoy was the doctor and( P8 H; \. N  Z; h( u 
Scotty was the engineer. And you sort of go, and what skill set did he have to get on this damn thing' R# Z3 u0 \; q8 Y1 Y6 [( f 
and run it? And, you know, clearly there is this skill set called leadership, and, you know, whether or 
5 H: C9 H2 ]) Snot you like the series, there’s no doubt that there was a lot to be learned about how to lead people  U. ]' k4 V1 L! W( U 
by watching this guy in action. And he just had the coolest damn toys! [laughter] [shows slide of; A; J; W3 w$ A6 g5 W 
Star Trek gadgets] I mean, my god, I just thought it was fascinating as a kid that he had this thing 
6 R* ?( b  ?) w! ~[Takes out Star Trek Communicator] and he could talk to the ship with it. I just thought that was just) E+ N' C5 _. n# u, p8 g2 t+ f 
spectacular, and of course now I own one and it’s smaller. [takes out cell phone] So that’s kind of 
$ |3 G& H+ T, D) S( Icool.% o. z# ~+ P: R( p7 g 
So I got to achieve this dream. James T. Kirk, and his alter ego William Shatner, wrote a book, which8 `; [% \: X1 B6 {6 o 
I think was actually a pretty cool book. It was with Chip Walter who is a Pittsburgh- based author& d8 M8 w& b' o7 f# Q 
who is quite good, and they wrote a book on basically the science of Star Trek, you know, what has 
2 B/ ?' r# q+ I3 _& [come true. And they went around to the top places around the country and looked at various things9 @' i5 j" W& Q" M 
and they came here to study our virtual reality setup. And so we build a virtual reality for him, it% P1 A3 K! g. q- ]" m0 ?- B7 P 
looks something like that. [shows slide of virtual Star Trek bridge from the 1960’s TV show] We put it 
( h; p( _+ k  u+ ?) n  h5 Lin, put it to red alert. He was a very good sport. [sarcastically] It’s not like he saw that one coming. 
  k' a3 S. }+ q9 [4 l2 b4 S- n[laughter] And it’s really cool to meet your boyhood idol, but it’s even cooler when he comes to you7 S) o% L2 @* D  R; ^3 p" z 
to see what cool stuff you’re doing in your lab. And that was just a great moment.6 B% W# v. |; U8 d8 C1 ]+ d 
All right, winning stuffed animals. This may seem mundane to you, but when you’re a little kid and 
* Y3 O5 B% h; g0 G* S( iyou see the big buff guys walking around the amusement park and they’ve got all these big stuffed( v5 ^0 U1 Q- O) L1 ~+ w7 b 
animals, right? And this is my lovely wife, and I have a lot of pictures of stuffed animals I’ve won.) [3 z: v2 H2 [, D: G  {% w' r 
[laughter] [shows slides of several large stuffed animals] That’s my dad posing with one that I won.6 N8 p3 n. y# e$ p$ N+ K% A 
I’ve won a lot of these animals. There’s my dad, he did win that one, to his credit. And this was just3 b! O% K. k1 x4 B& C8 I6 q 
a big part of my life and my family’s life. But you know, I can hear the cynics. In this age of digitally! Q, N  @8 J. v 
manipulated images, maybe those bears really aren’t in the pictures with me, or maybe I paid 
! O; w& @, Q* Z  n  v8 Xsomebody five bucks to take a picture in the theme park next to the bear. And I said, how, in this- P  N7 D3 _5 a5 @ 
age of cynicism can I convince people? And I said, I know, I can show them the bears! Bring them) M% H" P! h! T- f8 J 
out. [several large stuffed animals are brought onto the stage] [laughter and clapping] Just put them( K. f2 W2 `, g* g) C, j 
back against the wall. 
, k1 S( ^9 t2 w: g" q3 {Jai Pausch (Randy’s wife): 
) C' @: T& d1 h) s% CIt’s hard to hear you. [adjusts Randy’s microphone]6 V! V+ G7 _, y' B$ F 
Randy Pausch: 
5 |$ k) B, y% }, b* W! ^1 Z, d0 i: vThanks honey. [laughter] So here are some bears. We didn’t have quite enough room in the moving 
3 _( D) C  o% f! u" ?2 Qtruck, and anybody who would like a little piece of me at the end of this, feel free to come up and 
! n/ k8 m7 D* ttake a bear, first come, first served.9 V0 ^; e9 E4 a! X 
All right, my next one. Being an Imagineer. This was the hard one. Believe me, getting to zero  k* l/ b& Z, L 
gravity is easier than becoming an Imagineer. When I was a kid, I was eight years old and our family* O0 G+ ^$ u, e0 a 
took a trip cross-country to see Disneyland. And if you’ve ever seen the movie National Lampoon’s 
* i5 }1 ?8 |5 _, p1 TVacation, it was a lot like that! [laughter] It was a quest. [shows slides of family at Disneyland] And 
9 p3 ~$ l5 |4 }3 _% o- y" }3 @" ^8 H, kthese are real vintage photographs, and there I am in front of the castle. And there I am, and for& ?% m5 M! z# Y& E4 Z3 b 
those of you who are into foreshadowing, this is the Alice ride. [laughter] And I just thought this was 
# d9 a0 K4 s; ^; `7 tjust the coolest environment I had ever been in, and instead of saying, gee, I want to experience this, 
5 W6 z5 L9 Q$ \7 aI said, I want to make stuff like this. And so I bided my time and then I graduated with my Ph.D. 
( r7 Z" A  |' q: h1 @from Carnegie Mellon, thinking that meant me infinitely qualified to do anything. And I dashed off 
" s0 L& X, @; Z4 M/ Emy letters of applications to Walt Disney Imagineering, and they sent me some of the damned nicest5 \: q0 ~2 B  C# A) N5 i) {, h 
go-to-hell letters I have ever gotten. [laughter] I mean it was just, we have carefully reviewed your0 ]3 a6 p, G2 d0 R! t3 s8 H 
application and presently we do not have any positions available which require your particular 
- x1 o# `0 E6 y& Xqualifications. Now think about the fact that you’re getting this from a place that’s famous for guys 
% s& \( L" a* P, h5 S2 c; [+ Hwho sweep the street. [laughter] So that was a bit of a setback. But remember, the brick walls are6 P3 q" `, g& ?$ c9 m5 C2 j 
there for a reason. The brick walls are not there to keep us out. The brick walls are there to give us- `& m) A$ e8 Y* e0 Q 
a chance to show how badly we want something. Because the brick walls are there to stop the 
0 o) s+ V7 L9 U! i$ x6 r+ t% ^+ l7 xpeople who don’t want it badly enough. They’re there to stop the other people. 
* [9 k3 f! c! A9 l4 {) T2 s$ H; [All right, fast forward to 1991. We did a system back at the University of Virginia called Virtual 
3 K9 n4 o- R: `, n% m. W" N5 U% QReality on Five Dollars a Day. Just one of those unbelievable spectacular things. I was so scared 
% Z! d1 X$ h# b% c- R3 R! a5 j( p8 eback in those days as a junior academic. Jim Foley’s here, and I just love to tell this story. He knew( Q- O1 d6 H4 `+ ` 
my undergraduate advisor, Andy Van Dam, and I’m at my first conference and I’m just scared to 
% n* o* R0 R7 v# Edeath. And this icon in the user interface community walks up to me and just out of nowhere just0 f* p5 B, t) V$ R8 f4 x, R, l+ w5 a 
gives me this huge bear hug and he says, that was from Andy. And that was when I thought, ok, 
) m# c' c# q4 x' pmaybe I can make it. Maybe I do belong. And a similar story is that this was just this unbelievable1 n" t. b' T# R8 c. t 
hit because at the time, everybody needed a half a million [dollars] to do virtual reality. And1 @- d. w! g5 u+ h' W 
everybody felt frustrated. And we literally hacked together a system for about five thousand dollars 
0 d& Z# X: g1 E5 L1 w$ u/ Tin parts and made a working VR system. And people were just like, oh my god, you know, the 
& F! ^+ \- w9 P" ]2 oHewlett Packard garage thing. This is so awesome. And so I’m giving this talk and the room has just 
" I* Z3 W/ f! X0 ?) s) Z# Dgone wild, and during the Q and A, a guy named Tom Furness, who was one of the big names in 
4 o1 \& v6 ~+ ^# ~; p6 @/ v  f2 rvirtual reality at the time, he goes up to the microphone and he introduces himself. I didn’t know 
: e8 I/ u, ?9 n; r( y8 A! Bwhat he looked like but I sure as hell knew the name. And he asked a question. And I was like, I’m" h+ T2 W9 m. q0 t  S8 Z 
sorry did you say you were Tom Furness? And he said yes. I said, then I would love to answer your 
, \1 ?* P2 G( z2 v* squestion, but first, will you have lunch with me tomorrow? [laughter] And there’s a lot in that little 
- B! l) D; E/ k1 l9 ~# `" r0 Mmoment, there’s a lot of humility but also asking a person where he can’t possibly say no. [laughter] 
* w$ j2 l$ c" I* EAnd so Imagineering a couple of years later was working on a virtual reality project. This was top 
! H8 Z0 q5 e+ c$ Q: Hsecret. They were denying the existence of a virtual reality attraction after the time that the 
% l( ^' O$ B" d# d! j4 g% Z* Epublicity department was running the TV commercials. So Imagineering really had nailed this one: e- P9 F& @: |/ g: o+ m0 o 
tight. And it was the Aladdin attraction where you would fly a magic carpet, and the head mounted 
4 R7 Y1 G0 n# {6 sdisplay, sometimes known as gator vision. And so I had an in. As soon as the project had just, you: L+ R( U. Z+ o: Y% O 
know they start running the TV commercials, and I had been asked to brief the Secretary of Defense 
. |4 |* X! I$ a, B6 hon the state of virtual reality. OK, Fred Brooks and I had been asked to brief the Secretary of 
( h! x7 V! t2 Y7 tDefense, and that gave me an excuse. So I called them. I called Imagineering and I said, look, I’m3 P' X( t" Q/ I0 y. n+ q. P 
briefing the Secretary of Defense. I’d like some materials on what you have because it’s one of the0 S' L. z' N/ ^) D) g" \ 
best VR systems in the world. And they kind of pushed back. And I said, look, is all this patriotism/ x6 c' o" k  V 
stuff in the parks a farce? And they’re like, hmm, ok. [laughter] But they said this is so new the PR 
) E# `7 |8 G& P+ H' A  R; Xdepartment doesn’t have any footage for you, so I’m going to have to connect you straight through  N7 S; \& {# e: U" l" ^ 
to the team who did the work. Jackpot! So I find myself on the phone with a guy named Jon Snoddy$ Y& j7 `8 L1 N/ J3 Y 
who is one of the most impressive guys I have ever met, and he was the guy running this team, and 
3 A1 v. y. `8 Q6 v4 mit’s not surprising they had done impressive things. And so he sent me some stuff, we talked briefly 
& a& L4 j* _& {, u2 W8 Y; Eand he sent me some stuff, and I said, hey, I’m going to be out in the area for a conference shortly, 
0 D* P3 h. `; s  w$ Jwould you like to get together and have lunch? Translation: I’m going to lie to you and say that I. U' p; j& w: k( | 
have an excuse to be in the area so I don’t look too anxious, but I would go to Neptune to have 
( a# m6 y1 `0 W! i) qlunch with you! [laughter] And so Jon said sure, and I spent something like 80 hours talking with all' u& }8 O$ d6 ^4 _, {. \ 
the VR experts in the world, saying if you had access to this one unbelievable project, what would 
6 r* O- e) j2 A0 D6 Lyou ask? And then I compiled all of that and I had to memorize it, which anybody that knows me 
6 {8 ~- \/ U  v9 W( w; vknows that I have no memory at all, because I couldn’t go in looking like a dweeb with, you know, [in 
0 G, R) S! {# i5 d# Edweeby voice] Hi, Question 72. So, I went in, and this was like a two hour lunch, and Jon must have; @7 S; N7 s5 e2 u4 Z' {7 V! w 
thought he was talking to some phenomenal person, because all I was doing was channeling Fred# R; C% p: q. }5 j. I% X) S 
Brooks and Ivan Sutherland and Andy Van Dam and people like that. And Henry Fuchs. So it’s pretty8 w6 _3 Z4 E* L/ [! E 
easy to be smart when you’re parroting smart people. And at the end of the lunch with Jon, I sort 
# t) L; [* o9 |6 s, oof, as we say in the business, made “the ask.” And I said, you know, I have a sabbatical coming up. 
9 b6 {7 z1 S0 `6 N( UAnd he said, what’s that? [laughter] The beginnings of the culture clash. And so I talked with him# v. i0 W1 m4 i7 r3 K9 P3 W 
about the possibility of coming there and working with him. And he said, well that’s really good 
1 d0 o" A3 o! k$ E) Y4 Uexcept, you know, you’re in the business of telling people stuff and we’re in the business of keeping 
! C% s+ w9 `$ L1 Lsecrets. And then what made Jon Snoddy Jon Snoddy was he said, but we’ll work it out, which I" @6 T$ p) \+ \) V% w, a0 L 
really loved. The other thing that I learned from Jon Snoddy – I could do easily an hour long talk just 
' q+ Y" z% y" m# D- e- ^( H: ron what have I learned from Jon Snoddy. One of the things he told me was that wait long enough 
9 n. Q' E8 s; G3 C$ n4 _! Wand people will surprise and impress you. He said, when you’re pissed off at somebody and you’re 
2 v  c& L+ k( p8 Yangry at them, you just haven’t given them enough time. Just give them a little more time and 
9 B+ M1 Q4 \# Q; j% Lthey’ll almost always impress you. And that really stuck with me. I think he’s absolutely right on 
, i/ F! n( v7 U  x! e# Qthat one. So to make a long story short, we negotiated a legal contract. It was going to be the first –" x; c) e' \9 O/ r 
some people referred to it as the first and last paper ever published by Imagineering. That the deal" D- {  M: s: ^- L8 p 
was I go, I provide my own funding, I go for six months, I work with a project, we publish a paper. 
/ [0 J6 M- x: y$ b* z! H# [And then we meet our villain. [shows slide of a picture of a former dean of Randy’s] I can’t be all& e% y- i+ d# _4 Y, n/ W 
sweetness and light, because I have no credibility. Somebody’s head’s going to go on a stick. Turns. e: J* m; L+ f 
out that the person who gets his head on a stick is a dean back at the University of Virginia. His! n  W% Q. U+ P; G8 f 
name is not important. Let’s call him Dean Wormer. [laughter] And Dean Wormer has a meeting 
3 P. D+ c, u9 E& [" B2 [6 uwith me where I say I want to do this sabbatical thing and I’ve actually got the Imagineering guys to 
6 H2 b$ K+ F+ L4 p* X) t  [let an academic in, which is insane. I mean if Jon hadn’t gone nuts, this would never have been a& L+ v7 s& W4 p: l8 A0 Z; @5 w 
possibility. This is a very secretive organization. And Dean Wormer looks at the paperwork and he 
7 K; x; e: I# q: ~' esays, well it says they’re going to own your intellectual property. And I said, yeah, we got the3 F  Y" |0 I1 O) u' r! s" o2 q 
agreement to publish the paper. There is no other IP. I don’t do patentable stuff. And says, yeah,! ?9 S" ?" x4 y2 L! C" h- V 
but you might. And so deal’s off. Just go and get them to change that little clause there and then/ G! m% ?- C- Z- b) k" X 
come back to me. I’m like, excuse me? And then I said to him, I want you to understand how 
" ~( A( Q! r! A; P9 b8 W( ^2 aimportant this is. If we can’t work this out, I’m going to take an unpaid leave of absence and I’m just 
! q; x, M: v* W! h8 b( agoing to go there and I’m going to do this thing. And he said, hey, I might not even let you do that. I 
& x; l$ x& f) M0 a) F' \; y& U4 Cmean you’ve got the IP in your head already and maybe they’re going to suck it out of you, so that’s. a0 M. T' r  Q9 o  V% g: X* r 
not going to fly either. [laughter] It’s very important to know when you’re in a pissing match. And 
6 x; Q9 ~* P+ C8 tit’s very important to get out of it as quickly as possible. So I said to him, well, let’s back off on this. 
- a- G! l! l; JDo we think this is a good idea at all? He said, I have no idea if this is a good idea. I was like, 
: Y9 a1 _2 K, H7 k; |; {* s5 L# Z8 ^[sarcastically] OK, well we’ve got common ground there. Then I said, well is this really your call? 
3 |  T/ {- M" [- {5 t) YIsn’t this the call of the Dean of Sponsored Research if it’s an IP issue? And he said, yeah, that’s true.: d* d) z6 S. Q1 `( X7 ]2 ]6 Z 
I said, but so if he’s happy you’re happy? [So he says] Yeah, then I’d be fine. Whoosh! Like Wile E.+ ~# N# f' l% | 
Coyote, I’m gone in a big ball of dust. And I find myself in Gene Block’s office, who is the most  r3 V* }) n0 B" Q 
fantastic man in the world. And I start talking to Gene Block and I say let’s start at the high level, 
, _9 w$ k; O# }9 \2 T) f) `since I don’t want to have to back out again. So let’s start at the high level. Do you think this is a6 H% t' S' I% O7 j( } 
good idea? He said, well if you’re asking me if it’s a good idea, I don’t have very much information.# J# A$ H& H) l1 I: [% m 
All I know is that one of my star faculty members is in my office and he’s really excited, so tell me 
* \6 p0 I' V* Bmore. Here’s a lesson for everybody in administration. They both said the same thing. But think4 W0 j, {+ J# s7 ~$ h# ^$ S 
about how they said it, right? [In a loud, barking voice] I don’t know! [In a pleasant voice] Well, I7 v; T. I! k* G8 }0 F9 a6 _- ` 
don’t have much information, but one of my start faculty members is here and he’s all excited so I( a$ T! l0 y0 S 
want to learn more. They’re both ways of saying I don’t know, but boy there’s a good way and a bad 
, y1 J4 K& q' L$ D: C) xway. So anyway, we got it all worked out. I went to Imagineering. Sweetness and light. And all’s 
5 ~9 ~* j, P/ ^1 Q; A+ q% h9 ^well that ends well.* G/ D, c0 h" T$ | 
Some brick walls are made of flesh. So I worked on the Aladdin Project. It was absolutely6 `9 V6 ]$ h  Y: r& v+ Y( _% w) z; v 
spectacular, I mean just unbelievable. Here’s my nephew Christopher. [Shows slide of Christopher) ^% o; |* e5 r, U" `6 G 
on Aladdin apparatus] This was the apparatus. You would sit on this sort of motorcycle-type thing.3 d; f) [0 M8 j" } 
And you would steer your magic carpet and you would put on the head-mounted display. The headmounted6 k; ^: V/ h) Y 
display is very interesting because it had two parts, and it was a very clever design. To get 
6 n  }5 j$ ]" x  Q- Fthroughput up, the only part that touched the guest’s head was this little cap and everything else& J! r  \, z/ X2 ~. A 
clicked onto it – all the expensive hardware. So you could replicate the caps because they were 
2 D1 C# _. w8 K; xbasically free to manufacture. [Showing slide of Randy cleaning a cap] And this is what I really did is 
( `3 K2 w1 ]0 H* ^9 u$ u' oI was a cap cleaner during the sabbatical. [laughter] I loved Imagineering. It was just a spectacular/ w% {* i1 r2 t2 O, P1 K, d 
place. Just spectacular. Everything that I had dreamed. I loved the model shop. People crawling# c. T% a- ^; N3 a8 N+ Y" x 
around on things the size of this room that are just big physical models. It was just an incredible 
* C+ }' c7 L6 f/ g. {, H! Y) d( {! ~place to walk around and be inspired. I’m always reminded of when I went there and people said, 
+ K5 l! H. e) g( I; ~do you think your expectations are too high? And I said, you ever see the movie Charlie and the 
5 Z6 I& L8 {% o' ^/ iChocolate Factory? Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory? Where Gene Wilder says to the little& e6 k6 u5 [4 ^ 
boy Charlie, he’s about to give him the chocolate factory. He says “Well Charlie, did anybody ever% O5 k# m( a6 {: i# q 
tell you the story of the little boy who suddenly got everything he ever wanted?” Charlie’s eyes get- j1 T4 ?0 G' J) |3 X1 [: y( l- R) u 
like saucers and he says, “No, what happened to him?” Gene Wilder says, “He lived happily ever- \& \# X& l0 M/ N2 @* l 
after.” [laughter] 
4 Y+ ^( M. k7 J( aOK, so working on the Aladdin VR, I described it as a once in every five careers opportunity, and I 
6 c7 Y& F& S  N  G1 sstand by that assessment. And it forever changed me. It wasn’t just that it was good work and I got! h- r' d: |2 e. d: P% d 
to be a part of it. But it got me into the place of working with real people and real HCI user interface1 t$ E/ C8 ~2 L( V/ \. G 
issues. Most HCI people live in this fantasy world of white collar laborers with Ph.D.s and masters6 `# ^% I" @3 @5 s/ p9 g 
degrees. And you know, until you got ice cream spilled on you, you’re not doing field work. And 
2 A7 u2 V# L" c& `more than anything else, from Jon Snoddy I learned how to put artists and engineers together, and" b& c3 u; R! `; n0 ^ 
that’s been the real legacy. 
4 G8 l% V+ E/ E) m  y- O  _% QWe published a paper. Just a nice academic cultural scandal. When we wrote the paper, the guys at5 H. A% u# s5 w# w; P 
Imagineering said, well let’s do a nice big picture. Like you would in a magazine. [Showing slide of 
5 W1 j2 z! D# D0 P, Pfirst page of the paper, with a photo at the top that spans two columns]. And the SIGGRAPH6 L% I  h; Y( S% Z 
committee, which accepted the paper, it was like this big scandal. Are they allowed to do that?5 m* ]+ Y) h; k0 e 
[laughter] There was no rule! So we published the paper and amazingly since then there’s a 
1 H# M' s) \3 c) p* ytradition of SIGGRAPH papers having color figures on the first page. So I’ve changed the world in a3 I5 {: {; W$ T$ v 
small way. [laughter] And then at the end of my six months, they came to me and they said, you 
# E; I! G7 @8 Z, L* p; _7 zwant to do it for real? You can stay. And I said no. One of the only times in my life I have surprised 
6 i( ]" }: b6 P" Lmy father. He was like, you’re what? He said, since you were, you know [gesturing to height of a5 l3 C1 q+ S3 h' C# a 
child’s head],this is all you wanted, and now that you got it, and you’re… huh? There was a bottle of 
( j5 b7 v; s! ]) P5 z3 v/ ~Maalox in my desk drawer. Be careful what you wish for. It was a particularly stressful place.; O+ h# ~& |( n 
Imagineering in general is actually not so Maalox-laden, but the lab I was in – oh, Jon left in the$ ?5 p* T. D7 r( q6 v  X 
middle. And it was a lot like the Soviet Union. It was a little dicey for awhile. But it worked out OK.$ O9 j4 t6 N3 \) |+ w, b 
And if they had said, stay here or never walk in the building again, I would have done it. I would* {6 l' e) r0 x3 \ 
have walked away from tenure, I would have just done it. But they made it easy on me. They said$ `! _* f, |/ \5 v5 G0 E 
you can have your cake and eat it too. And I basically became a day-a-week consultant for- j8 i$ x7 q0 J1 c 
Imagineering, and I did that for about ten years. And that’s one of the reasons you should all 
  ?9 w) _- h% m( V4 F5 tbecome professors. Because you can have your cake and eat it too.& d, e! q* K* f! h 
I went and consulted on things like DisneyQuest. So there was the Virtual Jungle Cruise. And the* x1 L7 s, u# O( W8 g9 L0 o 
best interactive experience I think ever done, and Jesse Schell gets the credit for this, Pirates of the+ c: o% H* V+ S2 } 
Caribbean. Wonderful at DisneyQuest. 
1 J. {5 {- T& a1 E7 l+ ?7 f- d1 Z" vAnd so those are my childhood dreams. And that’s pretty good. I felt good about that. So then the 
; B0 H3 Q) Q- F' Dquestion becomes, how can I enable the childhood dreams of others. And again, boy am I glad I 
8 F+ N/ l4 q  |+ {4 Tbecame a professor. What better place to enable childhood dreams? Eh, maybe working at EA, I 
0 `4 {/ S4 V% `. U1 P. K- Vdon’t know. That’d probably be a good close second. And this started in a very concrete realization- h! n% E2 l, a( P  e5 B  z 
that I could do this, because a young man named Tommy Burnett, when I was at the University of% b2 d% S- Y! F8 E0 c2 w& t 
Virginia, came to me, was interested in joining my research group. And we talked about it, and he  z* P" B1 i+ G6 V5 f, p8 d 
said, oh, and I have a childhood dream. It gets pretty easy to recognize them when they tell you.$ J: b- d/ I$ K# x$ b$ B 
And I said, yes, Tommy, what is your childhood dream? He said, I want to work on the next Star 
. ?' v$ [" G9 s; M' K, Z/ X9 _4 {" [: XWars film. Now you got to remember the timing on this. Where is Tommy, Tommy is here today.8 N, N) q" F, j8 I/ A 
What year would this have been? Your sophomore year. 
( `7 R" Q/ l  w+ ?Tommy: 
3 {$ a7 I$ q* i6 c0 vIt was around ’93. 
' d3 ^+ T, k9 e9 g% k$ {Randy Pausch:1 C) K( C' t# q6 V4 e) r! k 
Are you breaking anything back there young man? OK, all right, so in 1993. And I said to Tommy,: I! E$ r' Q. z; ~! ^2 E 
you know they’re probably not going to make those next movies. [laughter] And he said, no, THEY& a- z( l* K! I4 S6 b 
ARE. And Tommy worked with me for a number of years as an undergraduate and then as a staff 
% z9 t; w( S* `4 w) Y8 N8 w+ ymember, and then I moved to Carnegie Mellon, every single member of my team came from Virginia 
0 T2 o3 B; r% O" Ato Carnegie Mellon except for Tommy because he got a better offer. And he did indeed work on all 
+ `% i0 w; A- [three of those films. And then I said, well that’s nice, but you know, one at a time is kind of) |5 {/ J( C4 C8 {  H/ k 
inefficient. And people who know me know that I’m an efficiency freak. So I said, can I do this in; P! {5 \( F0 Q2 D9 } 
mass? Can I get people turned in such a way that they can be turned onto their childhood dreams?1 ~  o9 [5 }0 [( \; y 
And I created a course, I came to Carnegie Mellon and I created a course called Building Virtual: M" R$ {, Z& A8 [/ t; U' ~ 
Worlds. It’s a very simple course. How many people here have ever been to any of the shows?9 a. m# p1 Z, S' R 
[Some people from audience raise hands] OK, so some of you have an idea. For those of you who 
2 a- n8 i* C5 Rdon’t, the course is very simple. There are 50 students drawn from all the different departments of 
1 Q/ W, t8 J7 _, C6 pthe university. There are randomly chosen teams, four people per team, and they change every 
2 v8 O; r2 h% o6 _/ L/ X3 Jproject. A project only lasts two weeks, so you do something, you make something, you show9 F. q+ m1 T1 m, t! C- s' Q 
something, then I shuffle the teams, you get three new playmates and you do it again. And it’s9 @. W' h( u$ ?- t7 |! U8 x  ]! P 
every two weeks, and so you get five projects during the semester. The first year we taught this1 w9 E* T0 p& k, k2 l 
course, it is impossible to describe how much of a tiger by the tail we had. I was just running the/ O' O, C; R# O3 W" _ 
course because I wanted to see if we could do it. We had just learned how to do texture mapping6 F1 D3 u/ O% z 
on 3D graphics, and we could make stuff that looked half decent. But you know, we were running 
3 {% Q  h+ T; |( ~4 g8 Jon really weak computers, by current standards. But I said I’ll give it a try. And at my new university# T. B! J7 E# U& d" Q9 D# v! ` 
[Carnegie Mellon] I made a couple of phone calls, and I said I want to cross-list this course to get all% n3 D7 I% E% o 
these other people. And within 24 hours it was cross-listed in five departments. I love this8 H" y* W, O8 p! y9 L. ], A 
university. I mean it’s the most amazing place. And the kids said, well what content do we make? I 
. Q( r* Q% ^& M( |1 w- |said, hell, I don’t know. You make whatever you want. Two rules: no shooting violence and no 
& h/ W0 L& E2 g  Wpornography. Not because I’m opposed to those in particular, but you know, that’s been done with) ?" _" ]$ U# ? 
VR, right? [laughter] And you’d be amazed how many 19-year-old boys are completely out of ideas 
; b& b6 ~: D& f8 `when you take those off the table. [laughter and clapping] 
8 y" w9 {* B) [8 O9 YAnyway, so I taught the course. The first assignment, I gave it to them, they came back in two 
* B3 G/ E2 G2 h) J, [weeks and they just blew me away. I mean the work was so beyond, literally, my imagination, 
# e( b( \. T  x& ~' [2 S" lbecause I had copied the process from Imagineering’s VR lab, but I had no idea what they could or 
* a0 z! \1 H) {# d3 [: U6 b$ ecouldn’t do with it as undergraduates, and their tools were weaker, and they came back on the first 
7 V$ J  |9 H' p# m, G8 Passignment, and they did something that was so spectacular that I literally didn’t, ten years as a' W7 E$ ]! W6 @+ k 
professor and I had no idea what to do next. So I called up my mentor, and I called up Andy Van 
  q. B' l# ?- BDam. And I said, Andy, I just gave a two-week assignment, and they came back and did stuff that if I" Q+ G" Y& z( }" ^ 
had given them a whole semester I would have given them all As. Sensei, what do I do? [laughter]% s7 e) m  Y7 o7 c 
And Andy thought for a minute and he said, you go back into class tomorrow and you look them in- h  \$ w. x7 K* o4 A$ W$ m: L 
the eye and you say, “Guys, that was pretty good, but I know you can do better.” [laughter] And that 
2 j- w* \: S; i, U! b/ bwas exactly the right advice. Because what he said was, you obviously don’t know where the bar0 e/ b  j' J$ T- n& v* P 
should be, and you’re only going to do them a disservice by putting it anywhere. And boy was that 
% P7 D5 Q9 L+ M9 y6 b9 Ogood advice because they just kept going. And during that semester it became this underground, c& |2 {3 `0 L9 k. s3 R 
thing. I’d walk into a class with 50 students in it and there were 95 people in the room. Because it 
2 R* m. D$ v  P1 dwas the day we were showing work. And people’s roommates and friends and parents – I’d never 
# L# C/ g& a; B& B( S" ?& U+ L2 X( Dhad parents come to class before! It was flattering and somewhat scary. And so it snowballed and" r; Z4 R+ v8 Y0 R" }$ H# t 
we had this bizarre thing of, well we’ve got to share this. If there’s anything I’ve been raised to do,& r8 g" H+ ~+ G0 h0 e 
it’s to share, and I said, we’ve got to show this at the end of the semester. We’ve got to have a big 
3 l# X+ U* V( W- u4 M5 D+ C1 Z$ qshow. And we booked this room, McConomy. I have a lot of good memories in this room. And we6 l; w9 O! A' Q% P. `0 B# q 
booked it not because we thought we could fill it, but because it had the only AV setup that would 
0 a* e6 N- q% ]! X" j" j: L/ ~work, because this was a zoo. Computers and everything. And then we filled it. And we more than8 l" o* {1 e# K- z& L9 p+ p# g 
filled it. We had people standing in the aisle. I will never forget the dean at the time, Jim Morris 
$ u  i- d% c3 E9 h/ ?1 Owas sitting on the stage right about there. We had to kind of scoot him out of the way. And the 
# o1 t$ q, |! ?energy in the room was like nothing I had ever experienced before. And President Cohen, Jerry 
9 o) i' q* G/ sCohen was there, and he sensed the same thing. He later described it as like an Ohio State football& x# o6 i! X+ A$ D0 y% T* ~/ a% |1 P 
pep rally. Except for academics. And he came over and he asked exactly the right question. He 
, k: z& G) \% p- C8 J" hsaid, before you start, he said, where are these people from? He said, the audience, what3 k# z3 r: g9 U5 T5 ~# o' p 
departments are they from? And we polled them and it was all the departments. And I felt very8 E: Q% m) ]- B% T* M1 e* d 
good because I had just come to campus, he had just come to campus, and my new boss had seen in 
5 ^, u8 V4 i9 \a very corporal way that this is the university that puts everybody together. And that made me feel" X! _( T0 j$ ~) e, L7 U0 ~ 
just tremendous.2 h6 B% e2 B: ?' U% Z7 n. c' u; b 
So we did this campus-wide exhibition. People performed down here. They’re in costume, and we; c' u6 E4 [* O; @  b 
project just like this and you can see what’s going on. You can see what they’re seeing in the head 
/ x# l" m) ]* n3 smount. There’s a lot of big props, so there’s a guy white water rafting. [shows slides of a BVW show] 
" I8 j( n9 j' Q7 m8 QThis is Ben in E.T. And yes, I did tell them if they didn’t do the shot of the kids biking across the" s; @5 _  N/ L# ? 
moon I would fail him. That is a true story. And I thought I’d show you just one world, and if we can 
& T: Q& Q0 R0 p. B: E6 F# Q, lget the lights down if that’s at all possible. No, ok, that means no. All right. All right we’ll just do; y: J6 X9 ?0 o+ P 
our best then. [Shows “Hello.world” world done in the BVW class, audience applauds at the end.] It5 c& S' e  Q  ~9 M0 o 
was an unusual course. With some of the most brilliant, creative students from all across the 
/ Q% K7 S9 a, u% k+ \0 Y4 W# icampus. It just was a joy to be involved. And they took the whole stage performance aspect of this6 G) d0 D4 I4 g 
way too seriously [shows pictures of very strange costumes students wore]. And it became this 
( J0 t7 C& m$ J' R/ Ucampus phenomenon every year. People would line up for it. It was very flattering. And it gave kids 
) M1 M, Y  o- I5 B5 n# t% na sense of excitement of putting on a show for people who were excited about it. And I think that3 B2 t7 r' @; i% z( m4 n1 Y 
that’s one of the best things you can give somebody – the chance to show them what it feels like to 
/ u3 @$ ^+ y, ^6 wmake other people get excited and happy. I mean that’s a tremendous gift. We always try to+ A+ P( Y) z6 c4 v. ]" w, h 
involve the audience. Whether it was people with glow sticks or batting a beach ball around… or 
7 z5 ]2 a% M7 p- Z* Mdriving [shows photo of audience members leaning in their seats to steer a car]. This is really cool. 
1 c* Q+ j# B, n7 hThis technology actually got used at the Spiderman 3 premiere in L.A., so the audience was; g1 ^/ x7 \9 k9 }4 w. }! ~ 
controlling something on the screen, so that’s kind of nice. And I don’t have a class picture from 
& ^8 G5 |! X0 w, O6 ^. ievery year, but I dredged all the ones that I do have, and all I can say is that what a privilege and an 
# x7 z1 G% q  W4 _: \, whonor it was to teach that course for something like ten years.$ F8 w8 g7 ]* U) I 
And all good things come to an end. And I stopped teaching that course about a year ago. People 
- G# }; K' D! [& f& L0 A' {always ask me what was my favorite moment. I don’t know if you could have a favorite moment.% ]! b( K8 j3 [: K; L. { 
But boy there is one I’ll never forget. This was a world with, I believe a roller skating ninja. And one6 F' S# _" n& W! s 
of the rules was that we perform these things live and they all had to really work. And the moment 
/ s' x( u1 W* d/ b7 cit stopped working, we went to your backup videotape. And this was very embarrassing. [Shows: _; z5 l1 {4 _; x; Z$ Q 
image of Roller Ninja world presentation] So we have this ninja on stage and he’s doing this roller 
3 [  }4 |0 D, askating thing and the world, it did not crash gently. Whoosh. And I come out, and I believe it was 
! D5 ?8 n: O# Q: t( N) g( RSteve, Audia, wasn’t it? Where is he? OK, where is Steve? Ah, my man. Steve Audia. And talk 
9 u; f4 f! _* o- [about quick on your feet. I say, Steve, I’m sorry but your world has crashed and we’re going to go to4 ]0 z8 }4 g, j" C; z; ]/ Z 
videotape. And he pulls out his ninja sword and says, I am dishonored! Whaaa! And just drops! 
* p& H3 s, N% b7 J[applause and laughter] And so I think it’s very telling that my very favorite moment in ten years of6 B3 G6 K" @, E6 z6 p- O( E5 P7 w 
this high technology course was a brilliant ad lib. And then when the videotape is done and the 
5 U6 R! |9 T1 k" z: blights come up, he’s lying there lifeless and his teammates drag him off! [laughter] It really was a. j! d7 V! T/ y* Q2 m" Y5 E  N 
fantastic moment. 
$ x, c* z% \' z2 h. d8 PAnd the course was all about bonding. People used to say, you know, what’s going to make for a  \4 c- B7 |7 c: T- R/ Z" A 
good world? I said, I can’t tell you beforehand, but right before they present it I can tell you if the 
' D1 ?5 ]5 c3 Y3 g! fworld’s good just by the body language. If they’re standing close to each other, the world is good. 
# [4 s2 `" V; R0 g% q. ^# t1 x2 P1 eAnd BVW was a pioneering course [Randy puts on vest with arrows poking out of the back], and I 
3 U6 d" I' t5 L0 i. m$ P; rwon’t bore you with all the details, but it wasn’t easy to do, and I was given this when I stepped& I+ p' O' y. `  P4 ` 
down from the ETC and I think it’s emblematic. If you’re going to do anything that pioneering you3 B7 p0 A8 Q  J 
will get those arrows in the back, and you just have to put up with it. I mean everything that could 
/ H9 T/ }3 G9 r$ q0 N' p  P6 Ngo wrong did go wrong. But at the end of the day, a whole lot of people had a whole lot of fun. 
. r- r+ Q. N! H' ?7 G/ v9 }& Q2 J- lWhen you’ve had something for ten years that you hold so precious, it’s the toughest thing in the 
2 B. U- w: ~# z7 t2 |9 vworld to hand it over. And the only advice I can give you is, find somebody better than you to hand 
3 l, a/ @. Q7 bit to. And that’s what I did. There was this kid at the VR studios way back when, and you didn’t have/ k2 q5 z# q$ j+ y; W3 y  a! c 
to spend very long in Jesse Schell’s orbit to go, the force is strong in this one. And one of my2 @: e* M9 v: P" U2 { 
greatest – my two greatest accomplishments I think for Carnegie Mellon was that I got Jessica) B8 U- i. T! ]1 ^7 E3 K- j 
Hodgins and Jesse Schell to come here and join our faculty. And I was thrilled when I could hand this- U% f5 R; _/ u8 _ 
over to Jesse, and to no one’s surprise, he has really taken it up to the next notch. And the course is 
4 R. j0 d- f: l7 E/ ain more than good hands – it’s in better hands. But it was just one course. And then we really took 
6 y2 Q! ~6 K) i' cit up a notch. And we created what I would call the dream fulfillment factory. Don Marinelli and I. l. U* S5 r5 g4 R1 W2 B" a% { 
got together and with the university’s blessing and encouragement, we made this thing out of whole 
% J/ @) p7 ~( ~$ ncloth that was absolutely insane. Should never have been tried. All the sane universities didn’t go* J1 h+ {4 Q! U3 m4 ` 
near this kind of stuff. Creating a tremendous opportunistic void. So the Entertainment Technology 
7 Q: C# X& q, CCenter was all about artists and technologists working in small teams to make things. It was a twoyear% U% \9 H7 p0 K) u+ C3 M( z 
professional master’s degree. And Don and I were two kindred spirits. We’re very different –; t+ l1 E. F% |0 T+ E$ E( \ 
anybody who knows us knows that we are very different people. And we liked to do things in a new8 D0 K; u" p9 r! F 
way, and the truth of the matter is that we are both a little uncomfortable in academia. I used to! K0 ?+ _# l: C, A, f 
say that I am uncomfortable as an academic because I come from a long line of people who actually1 h8 G, U- F9 _1 r( I* F 
worked for a living, so. [Nervous laughter] I detect nervous laughter! And I want to stress, Carnegie 
2 i5 A: L: v; y9 R$ Q4 Z2 {Mellon is the only place in the world that the ETC could have happened. By far the only place.0 I& P3 i$ t& h 
[Shows slide of Don Marinelli in tye-dyed shirt, shades and an electric guitar, sitting on a desk next/ C% N: H* i9 T$ x 
to Randy, wearing nerd glasses, button-up shirt, staring at a laptop. Above their heads were the 
! i4 q1 Z, c  H, v  m( zlabels “Right brain/Left brain”] [laughter] OK, this picture was Don’s idea, OK? And we like to refer 
4 f; d2 W+ c$ t7 G, R' tto this picture as Don Marinelli on guitar and Randy Pausch on keyboards. [laughter] But we really 
* l; i1 J5 ?. f7 v5 Odid play up the left brain, right brain and it worked out really well that way. [Shows slide of Don 
+ m, n& M% w5 p$ b9 xlooking intense] Don is an intense guy. And Don and I shared an office, and at first it was a small 
6 `% j$ J' P0 x8 poffice. We shared an office for six years. You know, those of you who know Don know he’s an 
: j+ P8 U3 r+ v1 Iintense guy. And you know, given my current condition, somebody was asking me … this is a+ M$ p4 I. ]/ k/ }1 q+ k5 w 
terrible joke, but I’m going to use it anyway. Because I know Don will forgive me. Somebody said, 
3 f+ {+ w: ]9 ^: ?given your current condition, have you thought about whether you’re going to go to heaven or hell?9 L/ ]5 H0 F. S- y 
And I said, I don’t know, but if I’m going to hell, I’m due six years for time served! [laughter] I kid. 
  l+ \  m1 y( [! r/ s9 H! wSharing an office with Don was really like sharing an office with a tornado. There was just so much! ~( Z. K8 H& B: V' {+ B 
energy and you never knew which trailer was next, right? But you know something exciting was+ P1 J) ?& J& r0 |+ k 
going to happen. And there was so much energy, and I do believe in giving credit where credit is 
$ m; i- t0 |# d9 X4 Udue. So in my typically visual way, if Don and I were to split the success for the ETC, he clearly gets 
6 f; \$ H. I; u$ K+ d* mthe lion’s share of it. [Shows image of a pie chart divided 70/30 (Don/Randy) ] He did the lion’s share 
/ }  e7 N( b! s7 c6 }of the work, ok, he had the lion’s share of the ideas. It was a great teamwork. I think it was a great 
( h! }% h3 R4 E& Hyin and a yang, but it was more like YIN and yang. And he deserves that credit and I give it to him 
8 L, ?$ ~# ~, b, W+ Dbecause the ETC is a wonderful place. And he’s now running it and he’s taking it global. We’ll talk 
# a& n0 M3 D9 A2 j- c) l  ?about that in a second.$ q( I1 |7 {+ j# ] 
Describing the ETC is really hard, and I finally found a metaphor. Telling people about the ETC is like 
1 A3 L& l7 |* Z$ m# f+ idescribing Cirque du Soleil if they’ve never seen it. Sooner or later you’re going to make the* C! T; E: h; p 
mistake. You’re going to say, well it’s like a circus. And then you’re dragged into this conversation! p* }1 r% h. z: F 
about oh, how many tigers, how many lions, how many trapeze acts? And that misses the whole4 B; j$ E; L7 I* H% N; L0 Y 
point. So when we say we’re a master’s degree, we’re really not like any master’s degree you’ve1 g* g) x  f3 }8 w& A9 M 
ever seen. Here’s the curriculum [Shows slide of ETC curriculum, listing “Project Course” as the only 
+ N9 x/ ^2 s  w% p2 Y. Kcourse each semester; audience laughs] The curriculum ended up looking like this. [shows slightly 
: l- |# z1 b1 Amore detailed slide]. All I want to do is visually communicate to you that you do five projects in( Z- ?- L( |1 D& V+ G 
Building Virtual Worlds, then you do three more. All of your time is spent in small teams making 
8 [1 J. Z% x4 ^% p6 j& _stuff. None of that book learning thing. Don and I had no patience for the book learning thing. It’s 
& q1 G* I+ f6 C+ `, a$ w* i: za master’s degree. They already spent four years doing book learning. By now they should have3 r# [8 T% m; t% {# v 
read all the books.8 z. D+ z7 |9 r4 ^) _& u 
The keys to success were that Carnegie Mellon gave us the reins. Completely gave us the reins. We- z0 V0 `$ v4 j+ J 
had no deans to report to. We reported directly to the provost, which is great because the provost 
+ J/ I2 \! p4 nis way too busy to watch you carefully. [laughter] We were given explicit license to break the mold. 
% R' \+ ?2 c9 p$ T; M1 GIt was all project based. It was intense, it was fun, and we took field trips! Every spring semester in9 y- N, N0 \" S' ~1 [$ f 
January, we took all 50 students in the first year class and we’d take them out to Pixar, Industrial 
% s' h& [2 y5 e+ a1 PLight and Magic, and of course when you’ve got guys like Tommy there acting as host, right, it’s 
9 \5 z" p$ L1 S: {pretty easy to get entrée to these places. So we did things very, very differently. The kind of* L* [+ o) h3 H% ?# y( L 
projects students would do, we did a lot of what we’d call edutainment. 
' e4 B, [5 s/ r1 PWe developed a bunch of things with the Fire Department of New York, a network simulator for 
. L  D0 o! j" ?, f# V( V3 Ptraining firefighters, using video game-ish type technology to teach people useful things. That’s not( a% G5 ^4 R; Y& R* a: E, r 
bad. Companies did this strange thing. They put in writing, we promise to hire your students. I’ve8 x& n" Y/ N( F% }& U 
got the EA and Activision ones here. I think there are now, how many, five? Drew knows I bet.. d6 G- b  U  i& Y% L" ^4 g 
[Drew Davison, head of ETC-Pittsburgh, gestures with five fingers]. So there are five written; D( G" N" B$ ]$ q1 B5 \% Q- W! q 
agreements. I don’t know of any other school that has this kind of written agreement with any 
1 Y9 m6 W8 m$ J- O* F: Xcompany. And so that’s a real statement. And these are multiple year things, so they’re agreeing to 
4 A1 q. V8 Y  ^3 uhire people for summer internships that we have not admitted yet. That’s a pretty strong statement 
- Z( U+ f6 B9 V7 j, c' _6 t( M+ Yabout the quality of the program. And Don, as I said, he’s now, he’s crazy. In a wonderful; S7 |! y8 _3 |4 u  T$ V+ ^6 G 
complimentary way. He’s doing these things where I’m like, oh my god. He’s not here tonight 
4 x: x3 a# ]0 F$ Hbecause he’s in Singapore because there’s going to be an ETC campus in Singapore. There’s already; n1 t1 N! L* k 
on in Australia and there’s going to be on in Korea. So this is becoming a global phenomenon. So I- W8 V, G* E' G! ` 
think this really speaks volumes about all the other universities. It’s really true that Carnegie Mellon# P) U# n  l6 Q2 o/ @ 
is the only university that can do this. We just have to do it all over the world now.6 f# H  H/ K0 ]: `6 q( I4 F 
One other big success about the ETC is teaching people about feedback [puts up bar chart where% W$ ?/ D2 u! k 
students are (anonymous) listed on a scale labeled “how easy to work with” ] -- oh I hear the7 ~- k5 P* V5 C: h 
nervous laughter from the students. I had forgotten the delayed shock therapy effect of these bar  ?, ~3 Q: M  v7 p0 Z 
charts. When you’re taking Building Virtual Worlds, every two weeks we get peer feedback. We put 
" p. _6 w. n% f, _2 x  \5 l/ Ythat all into a big spreadsheet and at the end of the semester, you had three teammates per project, 
& r0 F8 N% {4 w$ b0 P4 gfive projects, that’s 15 data points, that’s statistically valid. And you get a bar chart telling you on a 
6 o0 o+ m6 f  x2 c, T7 hranking of how easy you are to work with, where you stacked up against your peers. Boy that’s hard1 v. m7 P1 t* Y: g: c 
feedback to ignore. Some still managed. [laughter] But for the most part, people looked at that and 
: I. |; V; i2 w* l0 bwent, wow, I’ve got to take it up a notch. I better start thinking about what I’m saying to people in 
; r- [, }4 e2 ~" h- @( X$ @8 Rthese meetings. And that is the best gift an educator can give is to get somebody to become self- H' [# X4 D4 \7 M# n/ R 
reflective. 
+ A& o& l6 X' X$ B7 PSo the ETC was wonderful, but even the ETC and even as Don scales it around the globe, it’s still very 
( U. i4 M, N5 w) ^# `labor intensive, you know. It’s not Tommy one-at-a-time. It’s not a research group ten at a time. 
0 h; v' U, _  Y8 A! OIt’s 50 or 100 at a time per campus times four campuses. But I wanted something infinitely scalable. 
1 h5 d1 _* R0 N0 uScalable to the point where millions or tens of millions of people could chase their dreams with 
/ [/ u5 C1 s4 c# d2 O. k  L4 bsomething. And you know, I guess that kind of a goal really does make me the Mad Hatter. [Puts on" C, m( }# ~. c4 d) d 
a Mad Hatter’s green top hat]. So Alice is a project that we worked on for a long, long time. It’s a; [+ s+ H) u0 r) F8 w 
novel way to teach computer programming. Kids make movies and games. The head fake – again,) [3 ~8 `( Z! R 
we’re back to the head fakes. The best way to teach somebody something is to have them think 
! N! u% Q; h5 N2 T3 vthey’re learning something else. I’ve done it my whole career. And the head fake here is that 
: F& F% L" R1 I2 qthey’re learning to program but they just think they’re making movies and video games. This thing5 M7 F+ ]. v# B, E 
has already been downloaded well over a million times. There are eight textbooks that have been4 G  d  C- M& L- O8 q7 q3 k# k  f8 t 
written about it. Ten percent of U.S. colleges are using it now. And it’s not the good stuff yet. The# H- Q5 Y; E2 G; i 
good stuff is coming in the next version. I, like Moses, get to see the promised land, but I won’t get 
. v8 k$ V3 I  i' |to set foot in it. And that’s OK, because I can see it. And the vision is clear. Millions of kids having 
; E( ^- ^4 L$ r- Y2 ~4 lfun while learning something hard. That’s pretty cool. I can deal with that as a legacy. The next 
6 h& ~# R# {+ tversion’s going to come out in 2008. It’s going to be teaching the Java language if you want them to7 q& F0 E% Q9 w3 ^* {7 u 
know they’re learning Java. Otherwise they’ll just think that they’re writing movie scripts. And: s4 W1 r- Z4 ~6 N 
we’re getting the characters from the bestselling PC video game in history, The Sims. And this is 
2 p8 e- e9 N2 e# N% [) D1 lalready working in the lab, so there’s no real technological risk. I don’t have time to thank and6 h3 G' ?0 D4 h$ ] 
mention everybody in the Alice team, but I just want to say that Dennis Cosgrove is going to be5 C6 ^3 K4 |, d: p 
building this, has been building this. He is the designer. This is his baby. And for those of you who1 Y$ W# e, w7 B) C/ n 
are wondering, well, in some number of months who should I be emailing about the Alice project,' _% u  K! w: Q' X& V  z 
where’s Wanda Dann? Oh, there you are. Stand up, let them all see you. Everybody say, Hi Wanda. 
5 s, G$ x: L, L9 r; ?& GAudience:( ]) s6 Z! V/ k8 s 
Hi, Wanda. 
' r5 J9 ^8 N7 e6 P  j  w! ZRandy Pausch:: V) H/ O) v( A) r 
Send her the email. And I’ll talk a little bit more about Caitlin Kelleher, but she’s graduated with her+ w0 Z% D2 v  D$ Y5 b* A 
Ph.D., and she’s at Washington University, and she’s going to be taking this up a notch and going to 
- ]! C% ^/ F, K# ~2 ]4 l) z2 wmiddle schools with it. So, grand vision and to the extent that you can live on in something, I will5 y  B( D1 P+ [0 G5 h' |# M 
live on in Alice. 
1 e( r$ j* p: H! ^8 T9 E3 P, CAll right, so now the third part of the talk. Lessons learned. We’ve talked about my dreams. We’ve 
% \" L, \5 B6 p- ]  D4 Ntalked about helping other people enable their dreams. Somewhere along the way there’s got to be4 S3 F# U( x- w( }, q2 M$ U 
some aspect of what lets you get to achieve your dreams. First one is the rule of parents, mentors* K' v5 M. I3 I. W- P2 A& v$ z 
and students. I was blessed to have been born to two incredible people. This is my mother on her; b! o. e+ D( O% v 
70th birthday. [Shows slide of Randy’s mom driving a race car on an amusement park race course]0 P2 X1 r6 x6 Y 
[laughter] I am back here. I have just been lapped. [laughter] This is my dad riding a roller coaster5 x8 |* s  [7 n# W8 T 
on his 80th birthday. [Shows slide of dad] And he points out that he’s not only brave, he’s talented 
. T4 T5 w. W& i  Gbecause he did win that big bear the same day. My dad was so full of life, anything with him was an 
/ D9 j1 p% @  V# L1 v1 y$ s* q# padventure. [Shows picture of his Dad holding a brown paper bag.] I don’t know what’s in that bag,$ x4 K* W) I( R; K) r* Z 
but I know it’s cool. My dad dressed up as Santa Claus, but he also did very, very significant things/ }4 e, A1 x' f/ T2 i 
to help lots of people. This is a dormitory in Thailand that my mom and dad underwrote. And every 
; U8 ^5 U9 J/ V3 \% cyear about 30 students get to go to school who wouldn’t have otherwise. This is something my wife 
) Z+ K. D  T4 h  Y% G( |and I have also been involved in heavily. And these are the kind of things that I think everybody 
+ ^! k+ t- B  Z% Vought to be doing. Helping others.- ^( d+ _1 O6 O* | 
But the best story I have about my dad – unfortunately my dad passed away a little over a year ago 
& z( I# z7 S* {8 L– and when we were going through his things, he had fought in World War II in the Battle of the 
0 R( J# Q: H# a- H8 c+ o6 Y3 Y) A6 N! p% jBulge, and when we were going through his things, we found out he had been awarded the Bronze 
$ w' X) W8 ^4 \' ZStar for Valor. My mom didn’t know it. In 50 years of marriage it had just never come up. 
& v; G6 h6 R9 W* AMy mom. [Shows picture of Randy as a young child, pulling his Mom’s hair]. Mothers are people 
9 y7 t2 ^, O* cwho love even when you pull their hair. And I have two great mom stories. When I was here3 h' A9 q* x1 w# H9 f 
studying to get my Ph.D. and I was taking something called the theory qualifier, which I can 
0 I( N0 N/ U% J, R+ e& H( S' ?# i/ kdefinitively say is the second worst thing in my life after chemotherapy. [laughter] And I was/ W: n1 N% x, _$ D9 ? 
complaining to my mother about how hard this test was and how awful it was, and she just leaned1 r, d/ s5 X; A& @% _: w) o! V: w 
over and she patted me on the arm and she said, we know how you feel honey, and remember when0 c0 e& Y- e9 F. I, i 
your father was your age he was fighting the Germans. [laugher] After I got my Ph.D., my mother 
; i, H7 v3 {- [took great relish in introducing me as, this is my son, he’s a doctor but not the kind that helps people.% I4 s' r& B' a: Q, G8 j 
[laughter] These slides are a little bit dark [meaning “hard to see”], but when I was in high school I 
8 P7 j. d+ b  j% kdecided to paint my bedroom. [shows slides of bedroom] I always wanted a submarine and an 
( H. ~/ p* m$ @: W7 G8 `* eelevator. And the great thing about this [shows slide of quadratic formula painted on wall]) l$ q0 W/ M& o) V  R 
[interrupted by laughter] – what can I say? And the great thing about this is they let me do it. And# q' c! w) _8 c' {- j 
they didn’t get upset about it. And it’s still there. If you go to my parent’s house it’s still there. And* }; u8 a  e) _1 ] 
anybody who is out there who is a parent, if your kids want to paint their bedroom, as a favor to me1 q, F2 w+ @% o$ L+ O8 a1 Z' ~ 
let them do it. It’ll be OK. Don’t worry about resale value on the house. 
" o1 [7 r3 B8 r9 R' I( v/ JOther people who help us besides our parents: our teachers, our mentors, our friends, our 
2 @, x3 ~8 Q6 k4 [8 ]1 B9 scolleagues. God, what is there to say about Andy Van Dam? When I was a freshman at Brown, he 
+ p* ~$ y/ J/ M# o. ^, h3 w$ O1 Jwas on leave. And all I heard about was this Andy Van Dam. He was like a mythical creature. Like a; C* p8 x3 k/ S8 } 
centaur, but like a really pissed off centaur. And everybody was like really sad that he was gone, but 
- X( Y( U, f/ ?; \) P! s9 G3 }kind of more relaxed? And I found out why. Because I started working for Andy. I was a teaching3 r. Q$ \5 w* I6 A 
assistant for him as a sophomore. And I was quite an arrogant young man. And I came in to some6 Y' V1 L1 }* m" u 
office hours and of course it was nine o’clock at night and Andy was there at office hours, which is 
3 l/ I3 l/ b+ L. xyour first clue as to what kind of professor he was. And I come bounding in and you know, I’m just, z  i' |! W/ s 
I’m going to save the world. There’re all these kids waiting for help, da da, da da, da da, da da, da 
6 D4 E8 Q9 R) ?: F. N& Kda. And afterwards, Andy literally Dutch-uncled – he’s Dutch, right? He Dutch-uncled me. And he 
( y3 o5 V/ t8 \5 o: {' rput his arm around my shoulders and we went for a little walk and he said, Randy, it’s such a shame) r. }6 u4 q: ~  I  v 
that people perceive you as so arrogant. Because it’s going to limit what you’re going to be able to5 x& p0 ?/ Q" p# P 
accomplish in life. What a hell of a way to word “you’re being a jerk.” [laughter] Right? He doesn’t 
/ N% ^; a/ p, Asay you’re a jerk. He says people are perceiving you this way and he says the downside is it’s going 
6 h/ x! [0 Q% W4 n6 D/ Ato limit what you’re going to be able to accomplish.# Q9 p9 d6 }$ Y# K! e0 b0 Z 
When I got to know Andy better, the beatings became more direct, but. [laughter] I could tell you 
: V- ^# G% m" B/ q: ?Andy stories for a month, but the one I will tell you is that when it came time to start thinking about% O1 c: m$ |5 g1 \ 
what to do about graduating from Brown, it had never occurred to me in a million years to go to, T/ H+ d; l2 P6 s 
graduate school. Just out of my imagination. It wasn’t the kind of thing people from my family did.. I2 [  g: N( a3 S 
We got, say, what do you call them? …. jobs. And Andy said, no, don’t go do that. Go get a Ph.D.. q/ |+ j& [, G$ ]. E" z 
Become a professor. And I said, why? And he said, because you’re such a good salesman that any8 |# j4 j5 {' L 
company that gets you is going to use you as a salesman. And you might as well be selling 
6 M& \5 {4 k) M# ^something worthwhile like education. [long pause, looks directly at Andy van Dam] Thanks. 
* }( i$ Y. X* bAndy was my first boss, so to speak. I was lucky enough to have a lot of bosses. [shows slide of4 N! ?) E0 S! L9 t1 w 
various bosses] That red circle is way off. Al is over here. [laughter] I don’t know what the hell 
' w% s$ [8 w4 s/ nhappened there. He’s probably watching this on the webcast going, my god he’s targeting and he8 q6 ]! L8 _/ C5 ~/ B( N% j 
still can’t aim! [laughter] I don’t want to say much about the great bosses I’ve had except that they# ]) W3 Z  c& p* C 
were great. And I know a lot of people in the world that have had bad bosses, and I haven’t had to 
% P1 C! G/ v; d4 nendure that experience and I’m very grateful to all the people that I ever had to have worked for.) j5 W9 ]0 h% V( L8 _% ^ 
They have just been incredible. 
. L- J* b  I+ K$ Q/ A: }2 IBut it’s not just our bosses, we learn from our students. I think the best head fake of all time comes7 X: i# b7 T2 d) H0 H 
from Caitlin Kelleher. Excuse me, Doctor Caitlin Kelleher, who just finished up here and is starting at 
9 T5 C7 V) Z2 vWashington University, and she looked at Alice when it was an easier way to learn to program, and7 E2 V+ Z* b( I 
she said, yeah, but why is that fun? I was like, ‘cause uh, I’m a compulsive male…I like to make the3 H, X6 R& R; T  q  f. w 
little toy soldiers move around by my command, and that’s fun. She’s like, hmm. And she was the/ x' ^2 F( [$ F8 Z, n5 F 
one who said, no, we’ll just approach it all as a storytelling activity. And she’s done wonderful work1 L. S7 ]$ K3 S7 S8 O8 T* \: { 
showing that, particularly with middle school girls, if you present it as a storytelling activity, they’re 
* m' H8 H) Z9 n  s- j( d. ^P a u s c h P a g e | 19& ^, Q% x. C: d6 k1 f 
perfectly willing to learn how to write computer software. So all-time best head fake award goes to 
- n/ A, E% r. ?# w; [& oCaitlin Kelleher’s dissertation. 
6 S# g( b( ^! r- hPresident Cohen, when I told him I was going to do this talk, he said, please tell them about having! M& ?& U0 U7 }2 k8 J3 t7 r 
fun, because that’s what I remember you for. And I said, I can do that, but it’s kind of like a fish 
0 p* Z5 d# t5 y: O" p6 M7 mtalking about the importance of water. I mean I don’t know how to not have fun. I’m dying and I’m 
, n  [; X& J! O. Thaving fun. And I’m going to keep having fun every day I have left. Because there’s no other way to 
; `) h- ?. E' X) B1 Dplay it. 
9 j) U2 i  `% [. cSo my next piece of advice is, you just have to decide if you’re a Tigger or and Eeyore. [shows slide- Z6 N; |& n! [( j 
with an image of Tigger and Eeyore with the phrase “Decide if you’re Tigger or Eeyore”] I think I’m 
) o4 h7 K4 G, X- cclear where I stand on the great Tigger/Eeyore debate. [laughter] Never lose the childlike wonder. 
  `5 y1 ~/ d# b4 d5 jIt’s just too important. It’s what drives us. Help others. Denny Proffitt knows more about helping; }, H0 l' N+ U, l# N8 _4 I7 w+ d 
other people. He’s forgotten more than I’ll ever know. He’s taught me by example how to run a 
6 j% H/ R$ }+ ~3 r9 C" jgroup, how to care about people. M.K. Haley – I have a theory that people who come from large. S5 x1 L1 c) h0 O 
families are better people because they’ve just had to learn to get along. M.K. Haley comes from a 
6 q1 f% j; E: v% \! kfamily with 20 kids. [audience collectively “aaahs”] Yeah. Unbelievable. And she always says it’s 
, I/ V: z) U  T5 I: `- xkind of fun to do the impossible. When I first got to Imagineering, she was one of the people who# K2 e- b! T2 V% N( l/ }! K 
dressed me down, and she said, I understand you’ve joined the Aladdin Project. What can you do?: t/ L/ h% u8 D1 C 
And I said, well I’m a tenured professor of computer science. And she said, well that’s very nice6 z" d; @# f* J8 z; r4 D( _ 
Professor Boy, but that’s not what I asked. I said what can you do? [laughter]* B0 A- R( v: N3 W6 `, i1 X 
And you know I mentioned sort of my working class roots. We keep what is valuable to us, what we* G9 M1 v1 U- ]* t4 V: [7 z( Q 
cherish. And I’ve kept my [high school] letterman’s jacket all these years. [Puts on letterman’s! v0 u. ]% L9 v$ x2 H1 g% c9 G 
jacket] I used to like wearing it in grad school, and one of my friends, Jessica Hodgins would say, why) ^2 x0 D$ C$ A 
do you wear this letterman’s jacket? And I looked around at all the non-athletic guys around me' l$ x, e  `7 t) y8 \3 @ 
who were much smarter than me. And I said, because I can. [laughter] And so she thought that was 
) W& i; ?+ Y: c- H; i: aa real hoot so one year she made for me this little Raggedy Randy doll. [takes out Raggedy Randy]1 i0 a3 V6 E4 t5 U1 f8 g 
[laughter] He’s got a little letterman’s jacket too. That’s my all-time favorite. It’s the perfect gift for( d/ v' K- H+ ~6 z. M% H$ u+ R 
the egomaniac in your life. So, I’ve met so many wonderful people along the way., U  Y* E/ k% o; ]; O 
Loyalty is a two way street. There was a young man named Dennis Cosgrove at the University of. o# L; z$ J" ^& b4 `) i 
Virginia, and when he was a young man, let’s just say things happened. And I found myself talking 
- k& @. Z, I1 f7 ^) L  O# h" G: yto a dean. No, not that dean. And anyway, this dean really had it in for Dennis, and I could never4 C4 \" `  b+ C 
figure out why because Dennis was a fine fellow. But for some reason this Dean really had it in for9 }1 s! ]/ y+ h& I 
him. And I ended up basically saying, no, I vouch for Dennis. And the guy says, you’re not even 
1 F2 D/ ?# D) K% t- I7 ]( j. Ctenured yet and you’re telling me you’re going to vouch for this sophomore or junior or whatever? I' E0 h. h: m. g: B( N0 Q) l 
think he was a junior at the time. I said, yeah, I’m going to vouch for him because I believe in him.% o% L! |1 w) V3 t9 s; F 
And the dean said, and I’m going to remember this when your tenure case comes up. And I said, 
/ j+ H% N1 A8 |# E) O" V, ddeal. I went back to talk to Dennis and I said, I would really appreciate you… that would be good.$ o& p: N2 N& H4 d. K' H- M 
But loyalty is a two-way street. That was god knows how many years ago, but that’s the same7 @5 A1 z" o- L5 w( n! F) w. j 
Dennis Cosgrove who’s carrying Alice forward. He’s been with me all these years. And if we only* u* ~4 t! U, ^0 {+ G: H 
had one person to send in a space probe to meet an alien species, I’m picking Dennis. [laughter] You 
2 ]6 H: n8 w9 P$ _. Q7 hcan’t give a talk at Carnegie Mellon without acknowledging one very special person. And that would 
' Y) _; p" N6 q' `8 T" nbe Sharon Burks. I joked with her, I said, well look, if you’re retiring, it’s just not worth living6 N; v  Q& D6 q3 u- K 
anymore. Sharon is so wonderful it’s beyond description, and for all of us who have been helped by7 d: Y* _. f7 n 
her, it’s just indescribable. I love this picture because it puts here together with Syl, and Syl is great 
( y; q4 Z* k# F4 J% hbecause Syl gave the best piece of advice pound-for-pound that I have ever heard. And I think all. ?# J# F$ c( P& m" k: K 
young ladies should hear this. Syl said, it took me a long time but I’ve finally figured it out. When it 
) S% J1 r/ ]9 L* t/ n* y$ H- _comes to men that are romantically interested in you, it’s really simple. Just ignore everything they# F$ j2 o5 z2 f0 z 
say and only pay attention to what they do. It’s that simple. It’s that easy. And I thought back to 
" [8 ]  C1 n( ^8 X" n5 }8 P- Wmy bachelor days and I said, damn. [laughter]7 ?6 e0 T5 k3 G- `# }1 { 
Never give up. I didn’t get into Brown University. I was on the wait list. I called them up and they 
2 R0 K2 G3 U9 x7 E  F- ^eventually decided that it was getting really annoying to have me call everyday so they let me in. At# u9 x7 b& Y2 J# U5 @; Y0 C 
Carnegie Mellon I didn’t get into graduate school. Andy had mentored me. He said, go to graduate 
# ?* t( B% e. C  o7 ?school, you’re going to Carnegie Mellon. All my good students go to Carnegie Mellon. Yeah, you 
1 N: t2 m; d# H+ s7 h0 Pknow what’s coming. And so he said, you’re going to go to Carnegie Mellon no problem. What he 
. L; `2 }& {/ F4 J$ ehad kind of forgotten was that the difficulty of getting to the top Ph.D. program in the country had 
' k0 c( ~" A" v! R7 Jreally gone up. And he also didn’t know I was going to tank my GRE’s because he believed in me.8 ?6 H9 O9 p/ ~$ f5 { 
Which, based on my board scores was a really stupid idea. And so I didn’t get into Carnegie Mellon. 
  |. P4 U- C. e) M, L- z/ `. O: ~No one knows this. ‘Til today I’m telling the story. I was declined admission to Carnegie Mellon. 
$ q& Z) L$ T" y2 ?1 U& e. e( z: cAnd I was a bit of an obnoxious little kid. I went into Andy’s office and I dropped the rejection letter" h) K9 v# |; _4 c) X3 L+ Q. t 
on his desk. And I said, I just want you to know what your letter of recommendation goes for at0 C9 V: ~6 v2 Y& g3 B 
Carnegie Mellon. [laughter] And before the letter had hit his desk, his hand was on the phone and7 a0 K8 y6 I9 Q7 v9 n 
he said, I will fix this. [laughter] And I said, no no no, I don’t want to do it that way. That’s not the! J5 w* l: w: ~% J 
way I was raised. [In a sad voice] Maybe some other graduate schools will see fit to admit me. 
# y( y5 X- I0 ~- P; m; A[laughter] And he said, look, Carnegie Mellon’s where you’re going to be. He said, I’ll tell you what,0 ]% i, s) t# [+ m2 n6 y" L 
I’ll make you a deal. Go visit the other schools. Because I did get into all the other schools. He said,& w/ P" }& Y6 ~2 W0 A& X+ i 
go visit the other schools and if you really don’t feel comfortable at any of them, then will you let me* |1 j# {  ~) E( J 
call Nico? Nico being Nico Habermann [the head of Carnegie Mellon’s Computer Science Dept.] and 
6 \0 C9 O- n4 p- WI said, OK deal. I went to the other schools. Without naming them by name -- [in a coughing voice] 
2 x* K% c, p5 c$ \; C2 D0 sBerkeley, Cornell. They managed to be so unwelcoming that I found myself saying to Andy, you' w) \6 V5 i% @' D0 {- }! U( o: C 
know, I’m going to get a job. And he said, no, you’re not. And he picked up the phone and he talked. J6 P( F) @# e- @' z* |9 i 
in Dutch. [laughter] And he hung up the phone and he said, Nico says if you’re serious, be in his 
# u/ F+ C/ ~& l/ Y1 Coffice tomorrow morning at eight a.m. And for those of you who know Nico, this is really scary. So 
0 ~9 B0 }1 E8 v* d5 w$ Z0 vI’m in Nico Habermann’s office the next morning at eight a.m. and he’s talking with me, and frankly I# @3 l3 K1 v8 Y* C. ~ 
don’t think he’s that keen on this meeting. I don’t think he’s that keen at all. And he says, Randy,8 k, _9 p7 c; S$ ~# f 
why are we here? And I said, because Andy phoned you? Heh-heh. [laughter] And I said, well, since3 `3 n3 C. y! z* M: V 
you admitted me, I have won a fellowship. The Office of Naval Research is a very prestigious 
0 Z: m/ r6 \( H  S' _( rfellowship. I’ve won this fellowship and that wasn’t in my file when I applied. And Nico said, a4 b" |+ A4 d6 G: z- o# e 
fellowship, money, we have plenty of money. That was back then. He said, we have plenty of 
4 h5 \' O- L5 T" Z! \money. Why do you think having a fellowship makes any difference to us? And he looked at me.! f$ x5 F( Y: v  X2 J0 P5 y  u 
There are moments that change your life. And ten years later if you know in retrospect it was one of 
! W" e( s5 D1 N. }8 `. wthose moments, you’re blessed. But to know it at the moment …. with Nico staring through your 
  w3 }9 ]1 x9 JP a u s c h P a g e | 21/ N' f; ^- f5 x 
soul. [laughter] And I said, I didn’t mean to imply anything about the money. It’s just that it was an 
; `, u  P5 T. \honor. There were only 15 given nationwide. And I did think it was an honor that would be( Z# i& i+ R+ q: f 
something that would be meritorious. And I apologize if that was presumptuous. And he smiled. 
) [- B6 V* g" @And that was good.1 {0 y2 O, E$ ]7 f; J) v 
So. How do you get people to help you? You can’t get there alone. People have to help you and I" T( P  i% q4 K8 G0 k9 k 
do believe in karma. I believe in paybacks. You get people to help you by telling the truth. Being2 G$ q* J$ J3 S5 c( e" { 
earnest. I’ll take an earnest person over a hip person every day, because hip is short term. Earnest) E% o9 a; }- F4 h9 d- p 
is long term.6 B! o9 ]: ]8 x. q 
Apologize when you screw up and focus on other people, not on yourself. And I thought, how do I1 |; W% H5 e+ U 
possibly make a concrete example of that? [Speaking to stage hand] Do we have a concrete' Z' |9 j5 }6 H* u  R$ Q 
example of focusing on somebody else over there? Could we bring it out? [Speaking to audience]# J2 t9 l; h+ n( u- n1 T 
See, yesterday was my wife’s birthday. If there was ever a time I might be entitled to have the focus 
2 h9 R. t) @: P& Oon me, it might be the last lecture. But no, I feel very badly that my wife didn’t really get a proper& R1 b& z7 b+ C' r2 w4 x 
birthday, and I thought it would be very nice if 500 people— [an oversized birthday cake is wheeled1 b" M# |( t$ T+ N; |+ F0 I' W 
onto the stage] [applause] Happy—) I7 ^: }4 n2 }" H 
Everyone: 
: E5 F4 z# m3 ~9 I…birthday to you [Randy: her name is Jai], happy birthday to you. Happy birthday dear Jai, happy 
' c) Q: A" b- F; Z7 S1 b0 g+ t3 \3 ubirthday to you! [applause] 
4 Z% q/ D3 w* j$ ?[Jai walks on stage, teary-eyed. She walks with Randy to the cake. Randy: You gotta blow it out. The- q( \4 e/ v; O: ~ 
audience goes quiet. Jai blows out the candle on the cake. Randy: All right. Massive applause.]$ O  O' N  R5 F7 k' I7 G& L# C 
Randy Pausch:$ r4 b8 _8 u8 ]" r' s! ~ 
And now you all have an extra reason to come to the reception. [laughter] Remember brick walls let 
9 u5 V, k1 g( h$ A5 s" W! v) z. Ius show our dedication. They are there to separate us from the people who don’t really want to. K$ C6 f! b- _ 
achieve their childhood dreams. Don’t bail. The best of the gold’s at the bottom of barrels of crap. 
$ l, M0 D$ J! k$ @' I& }% E[Shows slide of Steve Seabolt next to a picture of The Sims] [laughter] What Steve didn’t tell you was8 M/ n7 O% _! ]. [0 Z6 N 
the big sabbatical at EA, I had been there for 48 hours and they loved the ETC, we were the best, we; I% Y/ x8 j7 m4 b$ C& A- G 
were the favorites, and then somebody pulled me aside and said, oh, by the way, we’re about to 
- v' M, Y8 m) N3 |2 qgive eight million dollars to USC to build a program just like yours. We’re hoping you can help them 
4 z8 D- {# w4 ~( G: ^6 }5 Iget it off the ground. [laughter] And then Steve came along and said, they said what? Oh god. And5 O+ x' b7 x, I 
to quote a famous man, I will fix this. And he did. Steve has been an incredible partner. And we8 H6 d( z' H( E* Y 
have a great relationship, personal and professional. And he has certainly been point man on 
0 T! N9 j  F- m1 \& Bgetting a gaming asset to help teach millions of kids and that’s just incredible. But, you know, it 
* J/ Y  U( f. J& |0 _. ]certainly would have been reasonable for me to leave 48 hours after that sabbatical, but it wouldn’t" R; A3 u6 f4 r! r$ f, ` 
have been the right thing to do, and when you do the right thing, good stuff has a way of happening. 
7 z0 l9 z0 L2 g9 a' vGet a feedback loop and listen to it. Your feedback loop can be this dorky spreadsheet thing I did, or 
6 H* V" G/ A; V, ?8 a# _7 T4 s2 ~) sit can just be one great man who tells you what you need to hear. The hard part is the listening to it. 
* B' _! j: e% U/ B0 b% L$ f. tP a u s c h P a g e | 22' A, y  Q$ r% i 
Anybody can get chewed out. It’s the rare person who says, oh my god, you were right. As opposed/ V3 s4 `+ F; A: ~ 
to, no wait, the real reason is… We’ve all heard that. When people give you feedback, cherish it and; B5 ~3 O7 s3 g# u3 U3 a 
use it. 
0 l. n  j/ o9 Q' U+ k" W* @- ^# _+ [3 B: PShow gratitude. When I got tenure I took all of my research team down to Disneyworld for a week. 
! Y9 y; P: z" R, D7 p' JAnd one of the other professors at Virginia said, how can you do that? I said these people just 
- ^* r8 t3 P* H' g6 Mbusted their ass and got me the best job in the world for life. How could I not do that?* r  ]" j0 t0 k4 w0 v, C6 L 
Don’t complain. Just work harder. [shows slide of Jackie Robinson, the first black major league 
4 g4 N1 c+ O' }baseball player] That’s a picture of Jackie Robinson. It was in his contract not to complain, even+ g/ A% o4 R( G9 f4 m# z; R+ z 
when the fans spit on him.4 |" o* {" P5 Z5 _' J& s- ` 
Be good at something, it makes you valuable. 
4 B7 f2 Z$ |" K* Y. P' k4 lWork hard. I got tenure a year early as Steve mentioned. Junior faculty members used to say to me,3 \/ f9 m2 w; W  ^- a$ ^3 R0 _) j 
wow, you got tenure early. What’s your secret? I said, it’s pretty simple. Call my any Friday night in 
" X  l/ N, C  rmy office at ten o’clock and I’ll tell you. 
( o# {6 h" @! t8 _) ?, WFind the best in everybody. One of the things that Jon Snoddy as I said told me, is that you might  f, I: y. _; C, h5 {! o/ Y 
have to wait a long time, sometimes years, but people will show you their good side. Just keep 
& f5 W7 F6 s+ h7 d- p) X& J8 ^waiting no matter how long it takes. No one is all evil. Everybody has a good side, just keep waiting,7 i+ o. V' b( _$ U, s6 p0 t' Z- D3 k 
it will come out. 
' i; S% {5 b2 k4 kAnd be prepared. Luck is truly where preparation meets opportunity. 
  W% y, C, k1 o* a) k4 |/ MSo today’s talk was about my childhood dreams, enabling the dreams of others, and some lessons 
# E1 N' E/ s4 x+ O  Ylearned. But did you figure out the head fake? [dramatic pause] It’s not about how to achieve your 
% p6 X  a( S- ddreams. It’s about how to lead your life. If you lead your life the right way, the karma will take care  P2 _' Z; O! A& H 
of itself. The dreams will come to you. 
4 r0 D# {; ]8 R1 P2 J+ ^/ fHave you figured out the second head fake? The talk’s not for you, it’s for my kids. Thank you all,2 T" b6 U. E7 a9 n% [- u 
good night. 
8 ~4 y; z, x3 {  B7 u[applause; standing ovation for 90 seconds; Randy brings Jai onto the stage and they take a bow; they sit4 Y' ~- O7 k  y4 V8 p7 \- T5 b$ B 
down in their seats; standing ovation continues for another minute]( P/ |) a2 b( O/ J7 n 
Randy Bryant:/ a1 Y2 n4 [- P 
Thank you everyone. I’d like to thank all of you for coming. This really means a lot I know to Randy. 
$ ]' S# w; k  Y" G4 z- i' I# VHe had this theory even up to yesterday that there wouldn’t be anyone in the room. 
+ \6 j- T  F2 K" l' I& cRandy Pausch [from seat]:' M7 C/ @6 v& j4 C! W 
After CS50… 
2 V: }: h# c- G, M+ E7 @0 PRandy Bryant: 
3 F5 I+ \5 U2 m3 Z- v' |I know. I’m the other Randy. That’s been my role here for the past 10 years ever since Randy( O4 A, z' ^1 S9 Z1 n 
Pausch came here on the faculty. And what I mean by that is, I introduce myself. I’m Randy Bryant 
6 {/ f9 l* _, J& _9 Kfrom Computer Science. They go, oh, Randy from CS. You’re the one that does all that cool stuff of  ]( H5 @& h2 l9 o5 f: \1 x: t 
building virtual worlds and teaching children how to program. And I go, no, no, sorry. That’s the+ N/ h6 P& Q1 L9 s9 {9 r& T) ] 
other Randy. I’m the wrong one. Sorry, I’m just like a dull nerd. [laughter] So, but I’m very pleased 
( S# m2 b9 o4 l, Otoday to be able to sort of run a brief series of ways in which we want to recognize Randy for his 
9 N- W+ v) q7 z: g: |$ n- r; G+ U3 Hcontributions he’s made to Carnegie Mellon, to computer science and to the world at large. So we 
9 F1 ?8 i4 R% ]) ~# p- L8 g5 D5 {have a few – it will be a brief program. We have a few people I’ll be bringing up one after the other., M' I1 ^" U3 v1 ~. H' j% ` 
I’m sort of the MC here. So first I’d like to introduce who you’ve already met, Steve Seabolt from1 m7 T  {, f0 K 
Electronic Arts. [applause]6 Q3 L9 Y5 }6 p/ |& m- ] 
Steve Seabolt:& X' z7 q5 x8 a& Z$ u 
My family wondered whether or not I would make it through the introduction. [voice starts to crack 
+ ~! ~7 W- B( f4 W& O1 \up] And I did that but I might not do so well now. So bear with me. As Randy mentioned, he and I, 
$ X2 |2 v% L# Q3 lCarnegie Mellon and Electronic Arts share a particular passion about nurturing young girls and trying% x% s6 n1 i& O7 Q3 D 
to encourage young girls to stay with math and stay with science. Every geek in the world shouldn’t: \9 j9 Z  G8 ?* A% I 
be a guy. You know, it’s such a twist of fate that there’s so many people that are worried about offshoring,' a: j# h4 l( `9 k" L 
and at the same time companies are forced to off-shore, there are fewer and fewer 
' k$ b  [- }7 Q2 d5 t* w: f" |students entering computer science. And the number of women entering computer science just 
( W) f+ s1 i" g! @keeps dropping like a rock. There are way too few Caitlins in this world. And Caitlin, we need so! {3 D/ N# L1 G. {0 _3 X7 W+ z. Z 
many more of you. And with that in mind, Electronic Arts has endowed a scholarship fund. It’s the 
  N) D7 M) B5 JRandy Pausch endowed scholarship fund, established in 2007 by EA. In honor of Randy’s leadership2 t+ O; s/ _7 t9 A 
and contribution to education, computer science, digital entertainment, and his commitment to3 s$ N$ f5 t3 \, T 
women in technology. This scholarship will be awarded annually to a female undergraduate CMU 
/ q! E0 [2 e  ^student who demonstrates excellence in computer science and a passion in the pursuit of a career in 
* M  a1 [  e6 V1 Uvideo games. Randy, we’re so honored to do this in your name. [applause]8 ]! [6 X$ L  K4 ]* c 
Randy Bryant: 
4 r5 G& L5 X& s4 l6 W( P5 RNext I’d like to introduce Jim Foley. He’s on the faculty at Georgia Tech and he’s here representing 
2 G* I& S, N" ^2 Xthe ACM Special Interest Group in Computer Human Interaction. Jim. [applause] 
+ i1 P* L. u$ V5 c- ]/ @4 A# {/ vJim Foley: 
% T: Z4 R& b  _  N[motions to Randy Pausch to come on stage; gives him a hug] That was for Jim. [applause] ACM, the 
* y! B0 @9 g/ U$ k  D9 _4 c+ AAssociation for Computing Machinery is a group of about 100,000 computing professionals. One of 
  Z/ i) j' V# U9 htheir special areas of interest is computer human interaction. A few weeks ago, someone who’s a7 Q7 t+ |1 M' [/ W" E3 o! l/ j 
very good friend of Randy’s wrote a citation which was endorsed by a number of people and went to 
* k, R/ {+ W3 jthe executive committee of SIGCHI, which on behalf of the SIGCHI membership, has authorized this% o5 e$ A- d2 j7 D 
special presentation. The citation was written by Ben Schneiderman and worked on then by Jenny! v# K* D" X  z" o) w/ V7 s/ V 
Preese and Ben Peterson, and endorsed by a whole bunch of your friends and now from the 
7 J, ]* F" O0 W7 K0 [2 Hexecutive committee. So let me read to you the citation. Special award for professional% ?0 R" j2 i! S1 d 
contributions. Randy Pausch’s innovative work has spanned several disciplines and has inspired both- A8 P3 X  }3 Q4 p* j) Y6 r7 i 
mature researchers and a generation of students. His deep technical competence, choice of( }! |7 A& K+ a. n- Z0 M  B 
imaginative projects and visionary thinking are always combined with energy and passion. We’ve" T, `( E4 c$ s 
seen that. From his early work on the simple user interface toolkit to his current work on 3D Alice/ K' J1 @* R) M" Z2 B1 z8 S/ y- H+ W 
programming language, he has shown that innovative tool design enables broad participation in 
# y# R& j! O, W6 c  f3 u  G. Cprogramming, especially by women and minorities. Randy Pausch has vigorous commitment to) U2 A- K0 Q  X+ A$ q 
engaging students at every level by compelling and intellectually rigorous projects, and his appealing 
7 H4 q6 }8 U  k* Llecture style for a role-model for every teacher and lecture. Yes, yes yes. [voice starts to crack up] 
, D' a" C3 I  ^4 t3 LHis work has helped make team project experiences and educational computing research more* V9 j0 k* f6 i% ? 
common and respected. As a National Science Foundation Presidential Young Investigator, a Lilly# \8 p; z# l& p6 _' Y 
Teaching Foundation Teaching Fellow, co-founder of the CMU ET Center and consultant for Disney( s/ @$ C9 s8 k 
Imagineering and EA, Randy’s done pioneering work in combining computing interface design and 
5 [+ ?& V( N, O' ~3 A/ w! Semotionally rich experiences. For these and many other contributions, the ACM SIGCHI executive: S9 S  Y3 z/ n7 r 
council is proud to present to Randy Pausch a special award for professional contributions. 
1 E0 f* L2 s8 y+ C# X1 c7 ][applause] [Randy comes back on stage to receive award]/ X9 ~# v! l1 T( R% B 
Randy Bryant:. M. h8 s) ^7 l/ v7 P 
Thank you, Jim. Next I’d like to introduce Jerry Cohen, the President of Carnegie Mellon University.1 `" T! ^  J0 U 
[applause] 
( o, Z5 g4 p/ r! H4 d. \. R7 zJerry Cohen: 
- I9 C  O; H/ ?Thank you other Randy. [Tries to move Randy Pausch’s bag of props to the side of the podium] You8 U: N0 C: [3 Z! T6 x& I 
know you’re traveling heavy, buddy. Many of us have been thinking about and talking about how 
+ O9 N9 H( M. S- ?. `we can recognize you on this campus in a way that is lasting and fitting in terms of what you meant" ^! t: Y; Z, [. V2 K5 m) X 
to this university. A lot of people are involved in this. You thought the provost wasn’t paying 
+ Y  M2 x8 U" O- {attention all those years. [laughter] Actually, one of the ways we’re going to remember you is this- F# \, R' x, ?7 _0 V& k 
$50,000 bill for stuffed animals. $47,862.32 for pizza. You’ve made great contributions, Randy, we 
% E; O0 h* U) m" |' j) areally appreciate it. [laughter] One thing we could not do, regrettably, is figure out a way to capture 
6 ^( b+ o" h  kthe kind of person that you are. You’re humanity, what you’ve meant to us as a colleague, as a0 E9 L% `) ^: F8 b5 J& |& N  K 
teacher. As a student. And as a friend. There’s just no way to capture that. There is our memories,: X$ k$ F4 r; I' B 
however. And there is a way to remember you every day, as people walk this campus. So we’ve 
& y" x. c( r$ M3 [& T7 d1 dcome up with an idea. You’ve done great things for this campus and for computer science and for. l0 ~+ G- C6 _3 {+ T 
the world. Surely Alice will live on. But the one we’re going to focus on right now is what you’ve 
2 [9 T3 j* f3 j/ {( udone to connect computer science with the arts. It was remarkable, it was stunning. It’s had: @2 N) V* ^3 k/ j 
enormous impact, and it will last, I daresay forever. So to recognize that, we are going to do the% M& J; @! g  Y5 m# j' u1 g. D 
following. Good job, other Randy. [laughter, as Randy Bryant gets the projector to show the next 
" {1 ~. o6 @* C7 v  Tslide] In order to effect this, we had to build a building. [Shows slide of mockup of Gates building] A 
' G' }2 ~4 j. ]& ?& Ghundred million dollar building which will allow us to do the following. You’ll note, by the way, to! n" ]$ u" l/ f 
orient people. So the Purnell Center for the Arts is the home of the School of Drama. That modern8 q  @  f" U. ]+ Y3 ? 
looking new thing, half of which has a green roof, is the new Gates Center for Computer Science./ x9 x% M" S! }; e 
And we had long planned to connect these two physically, both to allow people to get down from 
2 r: s- ^* t/ ^" j  L: hthe cut to lower campus, and you have to admit it carries tremendous symbolic importance. Well 
3 |7 n0 T  C& N% L  u' @7 ?on behalf of the Board of Trustees of Carnegie Mellon and on behalf of the entire university, I’m0 p' N: H7 |, q2 R; S9 o, y. u 
pleased to announce today that the bridge connecting these two will be known as the Randy Pausch( Y" z8 P5 w9 x 
Memorial Footbridge. [shows slide of mockup of bridge] [applause] Now actually based on your talk 
( B6 [/ O* x0 ?today we’re thinking now about putting up a brick wall up at either end, and let students see what0 h; Y  b2 b) A6 A 
they can do with it. [laughter] Randy, there’ll be a generation of students and faculty to come here: t/ G, V0 Q' n2 P) Y) o 
who will not know you, but they will cross that bridge, they will see your name, and they’ll ask those 
5 i* |, T+ }, Xof us who did know you. And we will tell them that unfortunately they were not able to experience8 ]7 A& u) X) N/ v 
the man, but they are surely experiencing the impact of the man. Randy, thank you for all that 
5 |" Z; l  V! c; B6 ?you’ve done for Carnegie Mellon. We’re going to miss you. [applause] [Randy walks on stage and 
4 B  h  `0 h6 K4 O8 xgives Jerry a hug] 
9 g4 }2 i+ {% _1 t, B( A5 }Randy Bryant:4 r$ h6 t2 k) Z0 T8 ^! a& a 
So every good show needs a closing act, and so to do that I’ll invite Andy Van Dam. [applause] 
* m- P* x2 j' rAndy Van Dam: 
3 b  _2 x; I  o: J$ g/ aOh how I love having the last word. [applause] But to have to go on after that fabulous show, I don’t 
; ]  |; [0 E$ n8 L* ?0 \know whether that was good planning. Well I started in Brown in 1965 and it has been my pleasure 
$ \9 n( Q+ Y! g9 B! J" }and great joy not just to teach thousands of undergraduates and some graduates, but also to work 
$ K" K" T$ o  u9 t3 fone-on-one with a couple hundred of them. And over 35 have followed me into teaching I’m proud 
0 k& R8 D- s/ ?# H  a8 Xto say. Out of those best and brightest it was very clear that Randy would stand out. He showed' Q* C& z' _3 v( K, @; y0 ^8 R 
great promise early on and a passion about our field and about helping others that you’ve seen) n  s: R' O- J' }6 M 
amply demonstrated today. It was matched by fierce determination and by persistence in the face5 s4 u. ~( x0 r% r+ ~; M 
of all brick wall odds. And you’ve heard a lot about that and seen that demonstrated as he fights 
5 {9 ~1 N' {3 d4 qthis terrible disease. Like the elephant’s child, however, he was filled with satiable curiosity, you; @* w2 E( s( Z 
remember that. And what happened to the elephant’s child, he got spanked by all of his relations,% g  Q2 s4 U9 u; { 
and you’ve heard some of that. He was brash, he had an irrepressible, raucous sense of humor, 
4 D! E3 V( P& U7 y. A; Jwhich led to the fantastic showmanship that you saw today. He was self-assured, occasionally to 
' n2 m# y* g1 M) W6 Ithe point of outright cockiness. And stubborn as a mule. And I’m a Dutchman and I know from 
" a! |' B) z3 K; t9 g  I& Dstubbornness. The kind way to say it is he had an exceedingly strong inner compass, and you’ve 
  d' J' V  I7 g0 Y5 ]seen that demonstrated over and over again. Now, having been accused of many such traits myself, 
5 d8 I0 E( c0 C4 v+ JI rather thought of them as features, not bugs. [laughter] Having had to learn English the hard way, I 
7 @+ ~& X" O4 m+ \! ~* N/ u2 S+ `was a fanatic about getting students to speak and write correct English from the get-go. And Randy4 x% e. i$ M6 O; L 
the mouth had no problem with that. But he did have one problem. And I’m having a problem with 
" `4 n% o( F( D7 y* I" K1 @my machine here, here we go. [gets slide to project on screen]. And that was another part of my! i9 `8 B4 c% K" D" @) i, v+ d! } 
fanaticism which dealt with having American students learn about foreign cultures. And specifically 
, I; o1 ]) B! j) u# cabout food cultures, and more specifically yet, about Chinese food culture. So I would take my  \, }% T0 O8 Q+ n 
students to this wonderful Chinese restaurant where they cooked off the menu using a Chinese6 k7 k% x. I; Y, S1 I3 G3 T 
menu. And I tried to get Randy to sample this. But would Mr. White Bread touch that stuff? 
4 {6 P; u- s+ s7 ]: m# T[laughter] Absolutely not. And worse, he refused to learn to eat with chopsticks. I was chairman at! i3 K+ V8 K3 n2 M; W8 h 
the time and I said, Randy, you know, I’m not going to let you graduate if you don’t learn to eat with7 V/ r8 G- q) Y, U 
chopsticks! [laughter] It’s a requirement, didn’t you see that? He of course didn’t believe that. And( N2 p0 i( c  w" P 
so it came time for graduation and I handed him his diploma. And this was the picture one of my 
' Y3 m1 u+ K3 w! B+ g4 m7 ^+ S/ U3 Zfriends took. [Shows slide of Brown University commencement, 1982, Randy dressed in his cap and. n0 E/ W0 G; a/ }9 o/ R3 F 
gown, opening his diploma, his mouth wide open in surprise] And what you see is Randy opening his 
  m9 W% k9 W; \! z9 \  \diploma to show it to his parents, and there was an autographed copy of the menu in Chinese and. {$ B' y! t+ v6 X  S4 F 
no diploma. [laughter, applause] It was one of the few times I got the better of him, I have to* ^8 {9 ~/ _. K4 L, g% X) k& u 
confess. Well here we are today, all of us, and hundreds and hundreds of people all over the 
$ S) x0 a. X, ~7 l. dcountry, I dare say all over the world, participating in this great event to celebrate you and your life.7 [9 J( D8 F" b% x$ u1 X 
Randy is the person, the Mensch, as we say in Yiddish. Your manifold accomplishments as a model 
; i( J8 T3 w5 m: z1 o, H' r/ h! [academic, especially as a mentor to your students. Your Disneyland expeditions not only were3 ^/ A  `1 j* f 
unique but they are legendary. You have more than fulfilled the terms of Brown University Charter, 
% t$ P: T! @1 Ywhich are: to discharge the offices of life with usefulness and reputation. Your utter devotion to, o! M' }+ p) b 
your family and your career are exemplary, and continue unabated as you cope with the immensity8 M; c4 f' w' s! ]! k% n9 V 
of your situation. You exemplify undaunted courage and grace under pressure. The most terrible 
* @1 C# B  }5 E( w: Fpressure one can imagine. Randy, you have been and you will continue to be a role model for us. 
& A4 d. |  w0 B7 k3 Q5 H6 c5 H[Voice starts cracking up] Thank you so much for all you have done for us. And to allow us to tell4 F& V# u. ^6 P3 p1 B4 ?7 k7 g 
you privately and in such a public way how much we admire, honor, and indeed love you. [applause] 
" \2 |6 y' x, S2 Y, N[standing ovation] 
* Q3 L8 o' Y* h  A 
) @! X/ s' M3 H( A/ q: z[ 本帖最后由 billzhao 于 2008-11-16 18:02 编辑 ] |   
 
 
 
 |