 鲜花( 1181)  鸡蛋( 48)
|
本帖最后由 小黄 于 2009-12-21 13:39 编辑 8 @( e# y2 e: x) `' [$ l* d
你也别整呢些弯弯绕了。你就说吧:CIVIC和卡车撞,谁比谁更吸能?谁比谁更容易死?( b1 T) l8 E1 \0 C4 J
降龙十八掌 发表于 2009-12-21 11:33 
9 d1 A, Z' [9 H4 rThere is no data available. If you do have some, please share. But please don't make up scenarios and data yourself, that's 意淫. Use a published source, or statistically controlled experiment.
: a/ e; d! v1 x7 @; `# `: D9 B. s% r0 M/ {+ H
From the existing data, there are 3 types of death:; Z# J$ Z0 W1 ^: ?6 N5 u( I# ?
1) MV: multi vehicle collision, like when a Civic hits another car/truck+ Q4 {. q/ I0 H
2) SV: single vehicle, like hitting a tree, or roll over
) l: }$ U: x8 G5 K7 E3) SV Roll: roll over, this a sub set of SV.
% Y1 L8 w, M: \& K8 d5 o- S
; I! o. M3 m, Z _ a6 r2 e9 e7 t( UFor Honda Civic:0 @$ c0 F; S0 U# f: R( M
MV 34# {( V8 A6 {! @( u; o
SV 33% O! A8 k b3 T* c2 q3 g9 T
SV Roll 13
$ V. G: F2 t# s* z1 i3 A
: w9 q0 Q1 e( N/ U( uFor Ford F150 (including super cab, crew cab):4 ^# N, H3 ^. M( O p$ ]
MV 28~34
. C7 P9 C" z0 O& [" b! e+ [SV 79~94
6 k j/ E! O! c3 _5 q4 s4 G& QSV Roll 48~82
* j" t, p" X$ I9 k+ U$ c6 r/ _4 F4 S q* E ]* ]* H2 P% g
For Chevy Silverado 1500:
/ N- l. M4 C) y6 d: W$ C4 HMV 40; d" e3 n4 Y9 B
SV 85/ }. q9 b8 H) v8 v9 R$ |8 m9 l% O) m$ O
SV Roll 61
# H8 y/ {- {, a; ?9 `, Y6 b$ }; p+ Y
As you can see, not only would the trucks roll over more easily, they don't perform better even in a vehicle on vehicle collision. So, yeah, Civic is definitely safer than F150 or Silverado. |
|